Proposed archival of FCP X XML adapter, Java Bindings, and HLS Adapter

[reinecke]

Hi all - I’d like to propose a few changes related to adapters and bindings and would like to hear thoughts from the community on them.

Remove the following adapters from inclusion in the opentimelineio-plugins package:

• otio-hls-playlist-adapter
• otio-fcpx-xml-adapter

Mark the following repositories as archived in github:

• otio-hls-playlist-adapter
• otio-fcpx-xml-adapter
• OpenTimelineIO-Java-Bindings
• otio-java-example

We will keep the current builds of the adapters alive in PyPI so users may still explicitly install them - they just won't be in the "batteries included" release. Should security issues emerge, we may however decide to remove them from PyPI.

Reasoning

The HLS playlist adapter was something I’d built for a previous use case that’s heavily dependent on including some custom metadata fields and only generates one specific (and probably less-common) flavor of HLS playlist. I'm not aware of its active use anywhere.

The FCP X XML adapter does not have an active maintainer and is in need of some serious attention to be usable in a lot of cases. I’ve had reports of people trying it and thinking OpenTimelineIO is broken because timelines aren't correctly translated. In its current form, I think it may be causing more confusion than utility.

The Java bindings were something we at Netflix advocated for. Since then, our need for them has diminished and we’re having great success using the python bindings. These bindings are pretty far behind the OTIO core implementation and without someone with clear interest in maintaining them, it’s probably most responsible to mark them as archived until someone wants to take up support.

For any of these repositories, if a community maintainer wants to step-up and get them into shape we could consider unarchiving and accepting a PR that brings them up to standards.

These decisions are not final and I'd very much like to hear community feedback.

[reinecke]

Given we haven't heard any dissent on this topic, I'm going to begin execution on the proposal - targeting beta 18.

The ticket for OpenTimelineIO-Plugins is OpenTimelineIO/OpenTimelineIO-Plugins#11