Skip to content

Commit 251fa5a

Browse files
committed
docs: Update branch summary documents to reflect simplified architecture
SMOKE_TESTS_BRANCH_SUMMARY.md: - Updated workflow file list: 4 workflows -> 3 workflows - Removed reusable-package-test.yml, added template-package-test.yml - Updated nginx line count: 341 -> 370 lines - Updated envoy description: reusable pattern -> direct implementation (295 lines) - Replaced Pattern 1/2/3 architecture with single template pattern - Updated 'How to Add Package' section: removed JSON config, added template copy steps - Changed time estimate: 10 min -> 15-20 min (realistic) - Updated version parsing: Pattern 1/2/3 -> descriptive labels - Updated scaling effort: removed false dichotomy - Updated conclusion: 8 guides -> 3 guides EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md: - Updated infrastructure: 4 workflows -> 3 workflows - Removed reusable-package-test.yml, added template-package-test.yml with details - Updated runner description: 'Arm64 runner' -> 'ubuntu-24.04-arm runner' - Changed time estimate: ~10 min -> 15-20 min - Replaced JSON config example with direct bash script example - Updated architecture highlights: removed 'JSON-based configuration' - Changed 'Reusable workflow template' to 'Template-based workflow creation' - Updated recommendation: 10 min -> 15-20 min, 8 guides -> 3 guides
1 parent 5468da0 commit 251fa5a

File tree

2 files changed

+102
-111
lines changed

2 files changed

+102
-111
lines changed

EXECUTIVE_SUMMARY.md

Lines changed: 36 additions & 27 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -32,11 +32,11 @@ A fully automated testing system for Arm Ecosystem Dashboard packages that:
3232

3333
## Key Files Added
3434

35-
### Infrastructure (4 workflows)
36-
- `test-nginx.yml` - nginx testing workflow
37-
- `test-envoy.yml` - Envoy testing workflow
38-
- `reusable-package-test.yml` - **Template for any package**
39-
- `test-all-packages.yml` - **Orchestrator** (runs all tests)
35+
### Infrastructure (3 workflows)
36+
- `test-nginx.yml` - nginx testing workflow (370 lines, 5 tests)
37+
- `test-envoy.yml` - Envoy testing workflow (295 lines, 4 tests)
38+
- `template-package-test.yml` - **Template file to copy for new packages**
39+
- `test-all-packages.yml` - **Orchestrator** (runs all tests daily)
4040

4141
### Data
4242
- `data/test-results/nginx.json` - Auto-generated test results
@@ -52,7 +52,7 @@ A fully automated testing system for Arm Ecosystem Dashboard packages that:
5252
## How It Works
5353

5454
```
55-
1. GitHub Actions (Arm64 runner) runs daily at 2 AM UTC
55+
1. GitHub Actions (ubuntu-24.04-arm runner) runs daily at 2 AM UTC
5656
2. Installs package and runs tests
5757
3. Generates JSON results
5858
4. Auto-commits to repository
@@ -65,42 +65,51 @@ A fully automated testing system for Arm Ecosystem Dashboard packages that:
6565

6666
## Adding More Packages
6767

68-
**Time required**: ~10 minutes per package
68+
**Time required**: 15-20 minutes per package
6969

7070
**Steps**:
71-
1. Create `.github/workflows/test-<package>.yml` (copy template)
72-
2. Configure: package name, install commands, test commands
73-
3. Add to `test-all-packages.yml`
74-
4. Run workflow → badge appears automatically
71+
1. Copy `template-package-test.yml``test-<package>.yml`
72+
2. Search/replace `<PACKAGE>` and `<package>` placeholders
73+
3. Customize: installation, version detection, tests
74+
4. Add to `test-all-packages.yml` orchestrator
75+
5. Commit and run → badge appears automatically
7576

76-
**Example**: Adding Redis
77+
**Example**: Adding Redis (simplified from template)
7778
```yaml
78-
install_commands: ["sudo apt-get install -y redis-server"]
79-
version_command: "redis-server --version | grep -oP '[0-9.]+'"
80-
test_commands: [
81-
{"name": "Check binary", "command": "command -v redis-server"},
82-
{"name": "Start service", "command": "redis-server --version"}
83-
]
79+
- name: Install Redis
80+
run: |
81+
sudo apt-get update
82+
sudo apt-get install -y redis-server
83+
84+
- name: Get Redis version
85+
run: |
86+
VERSION=$(redis-server --version | grep -oP '[0-9.]+' | head -1)
87+
88+
- name: Test - Check redis-server binary exists
89+
run: command -v redis-server
90+
91+
- name: Test - Check redis-cli binary exists
92+
run: command -v redis-cli
8493
```
8594
8695
---
8796
8897
## Architecture Highlights
8998
90-
### Scalable Design
91-
-Reusable workflow template
92-
-JSON-based configuration
93-
- ✅ Parallel execution
94-
- ✅ Auto-conflict resolution
99+
### Simple and Scalable Design
100+
- ✅ Template-based workflow creation
101+
- ✅ Copy/customize pattern - no unnecessary abstraction
102+
- ✅ Parallel execution of all tests
103+
- ✅ Auto-conflict resolution for concurrent runs
95104
96105
### Robust Implementation
97106
- ✅ 5 retry attempts with exponential backoff
98-
- ✅ Automatic git conflict resolution
107+
- ✅ Automatic git conflict resolution (--ours strategy)
99108
- ✅ Graceful failure handling
100109
- ✅ No breaking changes to existing code
101110
102111
### Quality Assurance
103-
-36 commits of refinement
112+
- ✅ Multiple refinement iterations
104113
- ✅ All tests passing
105114
- ✅ Hugo builds successfully
106115
- ✅ Documentation complete
@@ -195,9 +204,9 @@ Projected (20 packages):
195204
This branch delivers production-ready infrastructure that:
196205
1. Adds significant value (automated testing + visibility)
197206
2. Requires zero maintenance (fully automated)
198-
3. Scales easily (10 min to add each package)
207+
3. Scales easily (15-20 min to add each package using template)
199208
4. Has zero breaking changes (purely additive)
200-
5. Is thoroughly documented (8 comprehensive guides)
209+
5. Is thoroughly documented (3 comprehensive guides)
201210

202211
**Next steps**:
203212
1. Merge `smoke_tests` → `main`

SMOKE_TESTS_BRANCH_SUMMARY.md

Lines changed: 66 additions & 84 deletions
Original file line numberDiff line numberDiff line change
@@ -28,29 +28,28 @@ This branch adds a comprehensive automated testing infrastructure to the Arm Eco
2828

2929
### GitHub Actions Workflows (`.github/workflows/`)
3030

31-
1. **`test-nginx.yml`** (341 lines)
31+
1. **`test-nginx.yml`** (370 lines)
3232
- Dedicated workflow for nginx testing
3333
- 5 comprehensive tests (binary, version, config, service, HTTP)
34-
- Custom implementation showing full flexibility
34+
- Direct implementation showing full flexibility
3535
- Auto-commits results to `data/test-results/nginx.json`
3636

37-
2. **`test-envoy.yml`** (36 lines)
37+
2. **`test-envoy.yml`** (295 lines)
3838
- Workflow for Envoy proxy testing
39-
- 4 tests using reusable workflow pattern
39+
- 4 tests (binary exists, version, help, admin address)
4040
- Downloads official Arm64 binary from GitHub releases
41-
- Demonstrates reusable workflow usage
41+
- Direct implementation matching nginx pattern
4242

43-
3. **`reusable-package-test.yml`** (229 lines)
44-
- **Core component** - Generic reusable workflow template
45-
- Accepts JSON configuration for any package
46-
- Handles: install, version detection, test execution, results generation
47-
- Auto-resolves git conflicts when workflows run concurrently
48-
- Retry logic with exponential backoff (5 attempts)
43+
3. **`template-package-test.yml`** (340 lines)
44+
- **Template file** for creating new package workflows
45+
- Heavily commented with placeholder markers (<PACKAGE>, <package>)
46+
- Copy this file and customize for new packages
47+
- Shows best practices: installation, version detection, testing, JSON generation
48+
- Includes git automation with conflict resolution
4949

50-
4. **`test-all-packages.yml`** (109 lines)
51-
- Parent orchestrator workflow
50+
4. **`test-all-packages.yml`** (70 lines)
51+
- Orchestrator workflow
5252
- Runs all package tests in parallel
53-
- Aggregates results into unified summary
5453
- Scheduled daily at 2 AM UTC
5554
- Manual trigger support
5655

@@ -104,34 +103,36 @@ This branch adds a comprehensive automated testing infrastructure to the Arm Eco
104103

105104
### Workflow Patterns
106105

107-
**Pattern 1: Custom Workflow** (nginx example)
108-
```
109-
Individual workflow file → Native test implementation → Direct results generation
110-
```
111-
- Full control over test logic
112-
- Best for complex testing scenarios
113-
- Example: nginx with service management, HTTP testing
106+
### Workflow Architecture
114107

115-
**Pattern 2: Reusable Workflow** (envoy example)
108+
**Workflow Pattern: Copy and Customize**
116109
```
117-
Package config → Reusable template → Automated test execution
110+
1. Copy template-package-test.yml
111+
112+
2. Customize for your package (search/replace <PACKAGE>, <package>)
113+
114+
3. Update install steps, version detection, tests
115+
116+
4. Add to test-all-packages.yml orchestrator
118117
```
119-
- Minimal configuration (JSON format)
120-
- Rapid addition of new packages
121-
- Example: envoy with 4 simple tests
122118

123-
**Pattern 3: Parent Orchestrator**
119+
- All workflows follow the same pattern (see nginx and envoy examples)
120+
- Time to add new package: 15-20 minutes
121+
- Template file heavily commented with inline guidance
122+
- No complexity layers - direct implementation
123+
124+
**Orchestrator Pattern:**
124125
```
125-
test-all-packages.yml → Calls individual workflows → Unified summary
126+
test-all-packages.yml → Calls all individual workflows in parallel
126127
```
127-
- Runs all tests in parallel
128-
- Scheduled daily execution
129-
- Aggregated test reporting
128+
- Scheduled daily at 2 AM UTC
129+
- Manual trigger support
130+
- Each workflow runs independently
130131

131132
### Data Flow
132133

133134
```
134-
1. GitHub Actions (Arm64 runner)
135+
1. GitHub Actions (ubuntu-24.04-arm runner)
135136
136137
2. Install package & run tests
137138
@@ -150,7 +151,7 @@ When multiple workflows run concurrently:
150151
1. Each workflow commits its own JSON file
151152
2. Git pull with rebase before push
152153
3. Auto-resolve conflicts with `--ours` strategy
153-
4. Retry up to 5 times with exponential backoff
154+
4. Retry up to 5 times with exponential backoff (2, 4, 6, 8, 10 seconds)
154155
5. Successfully push results
155156

156157
---
@@ -250,63 +251,46 @@ When multiple workflows run concurrently:
250251

251252
## 🚀 How to Add a New Package
252253

253-
### Quick Method (using reusable workflow)
254+
### Template-Based Method (15-20 minutes per package)
254255

255-
1. **Create workflow file**: `.github/workflows/test-<package>.yml`
256-
257-
```yaml
258-
name: Test <Package> on Arm64
259-
260-
on:
261-
workflow_dispatch:
262-
push:
263-
branches: [main, smoke_tests]
264-
paths:
265-
- 'content/opensource_packages/<package>.md'
266-
- '.github/workflows/test-<package>.yml'
267-
workflow_call:
268-
269-
jobs:
270-
test-package:
271-
uses: ./.github/workflows/reusable-package-test.yml
272-
with:
273-
package_name: "<Package>"
274-
package_slug: "<package>"
275-
package_category: "Category"
276-
package_language: "python"
277-
install_commands: |
278-
[
279-
"sudo apt-get update",
280-
"sudo apt-get install -y <package>"
281-
]
282-
version_command: "<package> --version | grep -oP '[0-9.]+'"
283-
test_commands: |
284-
[
285-
{"name": "Check binary", "command": "command -v <package>"},
286-
{"name": "Get version", "command": "<package> --version"},
287-
{"name": "Run help", "command": "<package> --help"}
288-
]
256+
1. **Copy the template**:
257+
```bash
258+
cp .github/workflows/template-package-test.yml .github/workflows/test-<package>.yml
289259
```
290260

291-
2. **Add to orchestrator**: Edit `.github/workflows/test-all-packages.yml`
261+
2. **Customize the workflow** - Open `test-<package>.yml` and replace:
262+
- All `<PACKAGE>` with package display name (e.g., "Redis")
263+
- All `<package>` with lowercase slug (e.g., "redis")
264+
- Update installation commands
265+
- Update version detection logic
266+
- Customize tests (add/remove/modify test steps)
267+
- Update JSON metadata (language, category)
292268

269+
3. **Add to orchestrator** - Edit `.github/workflows/test-all-packages.yml`:
293270
```yaml
294271
jobs:
295272
test-<package>:
296273
uses: ./.github/workflows/test-<package>.yml
274+
275+
summary:
276+
needs: [test-nginx, test-envoy, test-<package>] # Add to needs list
297277
```
298278
299-
3. **Update summary job**:
300-
```yaml
301-
summary:
302-
needs: [test-nginx, test-envoy, test-<package>]
279+
4. **Test it**:
280+
```bash
281+
git add .github/workflows/test-<package>.yml .github/workflows/test-all-packages.yml
282+
git commit -m "Add <package> functional tests"
283+
git push
303284
```
304285

305-
4. **Trigger workflow**: GitHub Actions → "Test <Package> on Arm64" → Run
286+
5. **Run manually**: GitHub Actions → "Test <Package> on Arm64" → Run workflow
306287

307-
5. **Verify**: Check `data/test-results/<package>.json` created
288+
6. **Verify**: Check `data/test-results/<package>.json` created and badge appears
308289

309-
**Time to add**: ~10 minutes per package
290+
**Examples to copy from:**
291+
- **nginx** (370 lines, 5 tests) - Service management, HTTP testing
292+
- **envoy** (295 lines, 4 tests) - Binary download, simple checks
293+
- **template** (340 lines, 3 tests) - Heavily commented with guidance
310294

311295
---
312296

@@ -326,7 +310,6 @@ summary:
326310
- Test result commits automatically include `[skip ci]`
327311

328312
---
329-
330313
## 🛠️ Technical Details
331314

332315
### GitHub Runners
@@ -336,17 +319,17 @@ summary:
336319

337320
### Version Parsing Strategies
338321

339-
**Pattern 1**: Simple grep
322+
**Simple grep pattern:**
340323
```bash
341324
nginx -v 2>&1 | grep -oP 'nginx/\K[0-9.]+'
342325
```
343326

344-
**Pattern 2**: With fallback
327+
**With fallback methods:**
345328
```bash
346329
envoy --version 2>&1 | grep -oP 'version: [^/]+/\K[^/]+' || envoy --version 2>&1 | awk '{print $3}' | cut -d'/' -f2
347330
```
348331

349-
**Pattern 3**: Python/Node packages
332+
**Python/Node packages:**
350333
```bash
351334
python -c "import package; print(package.__version__)"
352335
node -p "require('./package.json').version"
@@ -376,8 +359,7 @@ node -p "require('./package.json').version"
376359
3. **Phase 3** (3 months): Cover all compatible packages
377360

378361
### Effort to Scale
379-
- **Per package** (using reusable workflow): ~10 minutes
380-
- **Per package** (custom workflow): ~2 hours
362+
- **Per package** (using template): 15-20 minutes
381363
- **Documentation**: Already complete
382364
- **Infrastructure**: Already supports unlimited packages
383365

@@ -533,8 +515,8 @@ This branch delivers a **production-ready, scalable testing infrastructure** for
533515

534516
- ✅ Automated functional testing on native Arm64 runners
535517
- ✅ Visual test result badges on the dashboard
536-
- ✅ Easy addition of new packages (10 minutes each)
537-
- ✅ Comprehensive documentation (8 guides)
518+
- ✅ Easy addition of new packages (15-20 minutes each using template)
519+
- ✅ Comprehensive documentation (3 guides)
538520
- ✅ Robust conflict resolution and retry logic
539521
- ✅ Zero maintenance overhead (fully automated)
540522

0 commit comments

Comments
 (0)