Skip to content

Bug: Pipeline.from_descriptor does not work for all steps #1764

@wkoch-cfs

Description

@wkoch-cfs

Hi, I believe i discovered a bug in table-pivot.

To reproduce, building off of table_pivot test:

 from frictionless import Pipeline, Resource, steps

    data = [
        {"region": "east", "gender": "boy", "style": "tee", "units": 12},
        {"region": "east", "gender": "boy", "style": "golf", "units": 14},
        {"region": "east", "gender": "boy", "style": "fancy", "units": 7},
        {"region": "east", "gender": "girl", "style": "tee", "units": 3},
        {"region": "east", "gender": "girl", "style": "golf", "units": 8},
        {"region": "east", "gender": "girl", "style": "fancy", "units": 18},
        {"region": "west", "gender": "boy", "style": "tee", "units": 12},
        {"region": "west", "gender": "boy", "style": "golf", "units": 15},
    ]
    source = Resource(data=data)

    pipeline = Pipeline(
        steps=[
            steps.table_normalize(),
            steps.table_pivot(f1="region", f2="gender", f3="units", aggfun=sum),
        ]
    )
    # This is OK
    target = source.transform(pipeline)
    print(target.to_view())

    json_descriptor = """
    { "steps": 
        [
            {"type": "table-normalize"},
            {
                "type": "table-pivot",
                "f1": "region",
                "f2": "gender",
                "f3": "units",
                "aggfun": "sum"
            }
        ]
    }"""
    source2 = Resource(data=data)
    pipeline2 = Pipeline.from_descriptor(json.loads(json_descriptor))
    # This fails
    target2 = source2.transform(pipeline2)

    # This also fails
    pipeline2 = Pipeline.from_descriptor(json.loads(pipeline.to_json()))

This fails with,

frictionless.exception.FrictionlessException: [step-error] Step is not valid: "table_pivot" raises "[source-error] The data source has not supported or has inconsistent contents: 'str' object is not callable "

In table_pivot aggfun is passed directly to petl, there's no check and conversion for it the parameter is a string. I would have also thought Pipeline.from_descriptor would contain the logic but it fails to export to json as well.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions