[Feature]: Provides a ```MenuFlyout``` like ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout```

### feature proposal

Provides a ```MenuFlyout``` like ```CommandBarFlyout/TextCommandBarFlyout```

##### ---------------------------

提供一个类 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 的 ```MenuFlyout```

---------------------------



### Additional context

在最新的基于 WinUI 3 样式的记事本应用中，我们发现了记事本应用使用的右键菜单是用 ```MenuFlyout``` 构建的模仿 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 控件，复原度将近 95%。这说明了 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 完全可以基于 ```MenuFlyout``` 实现，而不是单独构建一个复杂的 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout```。所以我在这边提议，希望 WinUI 团队能重新审视 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 控件，能在目前已有的 ```MenuFlyout``` 作出改进，而不是重新单独构建一个 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 控件。

##### --------------------------------------------------

In the latest WinUI 3-style notepad app, we found that the notepad app uses a ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout```-like control built with ```MenuFlyout``` with nearly 95% resiliency. This shows that ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` can be implemented entirely on MenuFlyout, rather than building a complex ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` separately. So I propose here that the WinUI team revisit the ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` controls and improve on the existing MenuFlyout, rather than rebuilding a separate ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` control.

--------------------------------------------------

使用 MenuFlyout 而不是目前的 CommandBarFlyout 控件的好处

```MenuFlyout``` 相比于 ```CommandBarFlyout``` 更轻量化，加载速度更快。
```CommandBarFlyout``` 的主题色存在问题，这一问题存在于所有的 WinUI 版本，到现在都没有修复。
```MenuFlyout``` 就可以实现 ```CommandBarFlyout``` 的功能，为什么要使用复杂的目前 ```CommandBarFlyout``` 控件?
```CommandBarFlyout``` 不支持自定义 ```CommandBarFlyoutPresenterStyle```，```MenuFlyout``` 支持 ```MenuFlyoutPresenterStyle```。
```MenuFlyout``` 有弹出动画，```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 没有弹出动画。

##### --------------------------------------------------

```MenuFlyout``` is lighter and loads faster than ```CommandBarFlyout```.
There is an issue with the theme color of ```CommandBarFlyout```, which exists in all WinUI versions and has not been fixed to date.
```MenuFlyout``` can implement the functionality of ```CommandBarFlyout```, so why use the complex current ```CommandBarFlyout``` control?
```CommandBarFlyout``` does not support custom ```CommandBarFlyoutPresenterStyle```, and ```MenuFlyout``` supports ```MenuFlyoutPresenterStyle```.
```MenuFlyout``` has a pop-up animation, while ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` does not have a pop-up animation.

--------------------------------------------------

记事本的模仿 ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout``` 的 ```MenuFlyout``` 实图

##### --------------------------------------------------

Notepad imitation of ```CommandBarFlyout```/```TextCommandBarFlyout```'s ```MenuFlyout``` real image

<img width="1074" height="392" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/7ebef70d-f113-428c-878a-0607716391c3" />

<img width="606" height="804" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/4d2125c7-ddb9-4691-ab2f-a83c7313791c" />

<img width="805" height="559" alt="Image" src="https://github.com/user-attachments/assets/5d795ceb-9df8-4bad-a607-1ec06ebb7412" />

Related issue
https://github.com/microsoft/microsoft-ui-xaml/issues/10731

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

[Feature]: Provides a `MenuFlyout` like `CommandBarFlyout`/`TextCommandBarFlyout` #86

feature proposal

---------------------------

Additional context

--------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Uh oh!

[Feature]: Provides a MenuFlyout like CommandBarFlyout/TextCommandBarFlyout #86

Description

feature proposal

---------------------------

Additional context

--------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------

--------------------------------------------------

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

Development

Issue actions

[Feature]: Provides a `MenuFlyout` like `CommandBarFlyout`/`TextCommandBarFlyout` #86