-
-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1.1k
Open
Description
Hello Home Assistant Team,
I maintain a custom integration (ha_ostrom) that has been running stably and used by many users for months.
In recent versions of Home Assistant and hassfest, however, I can no longer validate the integration because the translation files (en.json, de.json) are suddenly marked as "invalid".
Error messages from hassfest:
Invalid translations/en.json: extra keys not allowed @ data['step']
Invalid translations/en.json: extra keys not allowed @ data['error']
Invalid translations/en.json: extra keys not allowed @ data['option']
Invalid translations/en.json: extra keys not allowed @ data['success']
My translations/en.json and de.json contain keys like "step", "error", "option", "success" – as is common in many older custom components and core integrations.
The problem:
- The detailed schema including "step", "error", "option", etc. was previously permitted for custom components.
- Now hassfest only allows "title" and "description" – everything else triggers an error.
- This is not documented or contradicts previous behavior.
- Many custom components in the community use the detailed schema and technically still work, but hassfest now blocks releases/PRs.
Request / Suggestion:
- Either revert the schema validation for custom components to allow the "full" schema as before.
- Or: Please provide clear, visible documentation for the translations schema for custom components.
- Ideally: Allow custom components to use the full schema for better translation of setup forms and error messages.
Why is this important?
- Many developers and users rely on detailed translations, and the integration itself still works perfectly (except for hassfest validation).
- It doesn't make sense to limit translations for custom components, especially when the UI and setup process benefit from them.
Thank you & best regards,
melmager
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels