Proofs created between AnonCreds RS and Indy SDK are different

[TimoGlastra]

Cross-posting this from PR openwallet-foundation/credo-ts#1629.

The proofs created between AnonCreds RS and Indy SDK are different? It seems with Indy when revealing name and a predicate on age from the same cred it will create one proof, while now with AnonCreds it creates two proofs. I don't know if this has any security implications?

See the below structure for the difference:

CC @andrewwhitehead @swcurran

[TimoGlastra]

Indy SDK

{
	"presentation": {
		"indy": {
			"proof": {
				"proofs": [
					{
						"primary_proof": {
							"eq_proof": {
								"revealed_attrs": {
									"name": "76355713903561865866741292988746191972523015098789458240077478826513114743258"
								},
								"a_prime": "69990785802771130988873403821332780424736016716687280191941460383686707785636392128821163741620205319502633916291172945951359718470693408645384223468140415805768748290999612300411184692156050784476858581776993094614076504883116601359825785227673338643875143463281347588686942741067757041603009255552973887041109474816203277234428863590094028964400167288079765389845657999656248445450037914272256715229953205559949833637360813178525977572261009983384847778990992639630950838155232072692009760356102526457195850384043066398513795291168916580943455051613968012166438520780954973395588363613751230138211868046133982680693",
								"e": "139970031001223820827685956918335365258361498701913268937403284190420481130683044103978190225172181790427845537382265233783189065882661585",
								"v": "945551062417607438146468240190627982719938733772061544888443036476195590958949864482854168598847024917858282223645383996002246779699151319682556551888374844664482513767371385916256541596645304820790407917406628805259825836975543452363881685325918737768460969058785910765235986253701654067402531404267049872321088707579504575312740659950312985065717653338321348580890811120092153322696121817286832393908543182231186985578706722931020096239075391807252116310258403839260706417183116978606922660139586118680368463865027326244823261599754352675430966863614247011571721146707662751538018666085115056006000458739890415907487823401139152272075374740044974297902723733298732576185161499238549172564530084171278560517445378210531116389479806357290225253683845232173453323973206636684317736811045129924612369253461973200254129923715986058567703762138479127273145488764196203425295949876658974272156890154534563261216917627023109823",
								"m": {
									"master_secret": "11912713960614047875650286146536446410334935794774846411715403491251705338762207655773408981123401237359274634877986791353035498077930684464113253437510127144065321722790526323157",
									"age": "9392431168881325707109344324207252900952522763209586100127186177941461926546855427551069423190994657569896056061022161456299816607801360795482647188153085736954496362039106624011",
									"image_0": "5927136900003523744646481932835203572645568479496337756626011763015475460552420736062127833395429187769438015833625363846202144093402965740873902817518466402337571703525224855008",
									"image_1": "1792066265441424220754699664357779726289222500741094698050924087484689551511831956853250459080706995842744001279863079717191050550796112581993481003748104081857387849753063789823"
								},
								"m2": "676120801917629370746289124732858339186888276571941679396903287015661727175723325851982766363292316103083125108670994237056229760706540712156535917409265268038653165062226557361"
							},
							"ge_proofs": [
								{
									"u": {
										"0": "11190408622552819626023578764433037932548890666062620014862128663891289152292071738061694672685570462157665096853453021611544185011966194581612624493020345122196222625562136165930",
										"1": "5650663800983500502237708766145353296227847511690810624001431493768935501358507563708811521486661448044208254141457959986705329635440448842074050922331154814277063506956544374660",
										"2": "11729622141062550548782037392645843680546307742994800926416492341613650326324265471851195511807074636440998342103074168373892137721612187292576691573625046587490169836066674078951",
										"3": "13310106614279007312701908256800459949127036794268670595602725268601152998350900607997860326910986947419500217949488769434778286604647585319324915523074202221035207828040664027630"
									},
									"r": {
										"0": "1738990246201821285300143378656910728119669956851089614681875403879530915003678715710778335461539472750346044049296288906656274870212364480239733952235914854041946787827849340182952252485650631587346285466335833396159842753996644794987943937687816989708002385486758824360286604042920616901634596785839132873622284902217346540100094207415311082566702442701975671211473260094440172962999209959879001426620286433199113441982221951462653084734887637283827666717233512031740639633894631091101437155771555892857539297030262290990276681711633912975641985608649645357083379935061300851271490145803260678991957096691274231277925774582115703387358538204520943299911795694112433161623197961536784058582153376184781102901799991382",
										"1": "3107417739723124273791350640124433100944260636348036064444986846372943878440500769074378842890979418053757945843122071210828045001668530522849154123012031024785713034658102103215361482022294408431201807965267793817499213623760992293411455236924148206345110580156711631750037634028264339825898128115566848518090341815829050066245047182703635296572509156416658948425790897859390754876331186123034969071540715804176591947213115055791692057659736892783098314942891428048856887325189844513387822931446726783959583517740656140416425354233171545673017389421003868046370440783188366696679157951171571449696974186951593568534214863269362716004577455576295301022266454106170671246565950861764902013081470821728937762894019602978",
										"2": "2588708262617025401110727838496605952075904234251410814745785876257694785393490401705521953321819350876442751116113530551709302248356058202862526476626412048718215847914684324294851849422670287057569275723365615547110913934863265070732702634733377885537839601310140330160660351577161482290912964015866212731549803018360910375520909563570972036584825904808313708381561557654510685453335603810053051716954783001016006569124888228308993861641160437500242347365355919515633529997370055417362367264242638592154608885415110008685113567097821959908151426265358622240961744286644479493440074093398648416874402390845084385520509829390049608885891195779608791803697863701323291491220956676713170102481011815118055229655519755684",
										"3": "2965949195910454781882529332150203727688282873036821815914902798212936894457192971007190897876492048562295457456633751403824889561135818758105823814463116045877651393863517461307341850736212747918779211608769992062161846795410836219925080462835084691149064541396469735771417408094057108083795212224638593557524454584593835126064757622597496845461339265690298092743833356647449156243886807664455330464856155130928857960815564484756168065066234349850692228755868921152969190566738726771634475593432499385337041103116234016050790278069059838119052477790183903484355250110176521974425650072858606075891567261371659632514190245410787901343581707457516898306034967260758895025456022822128982939615635023592887087458311795257",
										"DELTA": "2952400626731837301519683517876351820195223085477348045918351102947220534988719183761346582014081715185640559131833578692722588223173712880229340055719282005250489448351904209142780170637747916686461844060472216210965015589343353806390540881136215700665480390853913648507131594853893853004533566924160903082797288604743110049505814178177818289046178581936046943840451394909097685371204845778495109815332949129689125729023939626048968064287598018667997532656544121066507216017698639276241863741823453624097322278187104654675103550272182247946674940991813130612699170493732823699912861480859722492043382426436466873822863092209922870729922981264856335895449768499319270592017539383970725100534454446271883350088546560110"
									},
									"mj": "9392431168881325707109344324207252900952522763209586100127186177941461926546855427551069423190994657569896056061022161456299816607801360795482647188153085736954496362039106624011",
									"alpha": "1704742653689062641669896883926378425070116902768189058595002445494952776929377844209291044911467732558107842722229690538733835413601367752514946261891497633863594543247981466391644692797934245973227956094007897524055562927970731914541698145500257776245910180623713758891633663056202982531529433241156730580075334701838250206513198155302305361346835445826031488018929206404207606459326129653871832634295145106146431228309745147485361999220652018113756928614870723511794669574291833855571778898051507090362535302961103625826135658668962043957351525240663645831328142555045519101560029427177637189155786649052083139467775447726461910692903783122247170756505688280725533682699511408376913120953065532738140602629664281563837388650744145219339482619561910340480172872388208666154129041733813216881458843653829534918073692405852843786253729209",
									"t": {
										"0": "83199544867787744079808931048886875988682622377121268027057484915017145975449477755456624035222312831840467860296048511742894601125006485755540174560879115170979427890209614172111121559117787521041685015274075509329281711833722268804151264640559565326683610675651983706291385050734273609039888644667325895682367224338315243863450054944403452051097026557405579450235706184373213848017504818535746678099623311459651206326087564809235655678990596362873954758779589017650478801691943287057983314498973439909374162910911279033758869019544235527505437709736360206898727132817741486622484763873350645255140100290889226736086",
										"1": "26766470343981455430723143653901415120867357321777551914456493214726664457931482831676569557646469740524299171450011854132443780420926213428030919313964684226098239880796548709662707090944992245954172076104527916808763964194224012267518307894287644439275304723548940200356990116800459684663607626652643365112509719440066523190877590594469020752999487003597891739327858202252593049409531218261911483704946810917856013673931379594780244793117030494616485452772019338205790955422402614817793796729901878721333398267339514889556232355740618622921139118394877879987814786873118327785403790420472612338783336222044362900936",
										"2": "41638972153207373129650332764221801564491242920805454869298401873022692401464041955712036092832064108943542339662363949572017129651114823114266591311257340701844877271638760784912410277489340674778740785010718276839875298132939491644064009195852220478639213038239942287016943664056207837731978425354221848387152894913800006095085824319762436811885454406184154044162880499159745107092634358270216042984075120431435126198022432887537393722195647213319470353958726720846733318044590284316098894332305900243100233414140844955919548510481040824572875238130997846471382028035545031936311376283250711916718603446801995298165",
										"3": "47863274107963502610075867404336037903104496701343494858601124002223958931927294249600987596488575173977168961137256456743990216833392917796913485722573207279008813485376757120979993762652140709557307247164937895559377776090481966663586713245443117380778743294059073042869016590371899097702101105047122077409668550273224264697558908430768829223971796417480718526692620917721694921248200223182024113434446407610459951640785255492412609342439180130464237426938236606944200989932458050218906020307570214142644035233347606631871077914382489065854471862585527207208093019688678680456617186250080935985150296540430956599441",
										"DELTA": "50767151662284027749439161273201843432852846551251868520252885267573161473903334770292701588765970808323342028562529659587925454290778966783987600008983582832041952156421104812431515435800031283302567203063388901745951265208384487084840955108406739018536684526177380612709696141636778304104146177867709396819839524065783504360896634480961505222169320709520251177746887919085275225344068372124469198944099037888208808693800107736199165093549121863674035231653560138848493130185648099348104314238212255898004573311949422671360786953479910831848409955782180449404669115956969772389555263470804178357416706587823082675671"
									},
									"predicate": {
										"attr_name": "age",
										"p_type": "GE",
										"value": 50
									}
								}
							]
						},
						"non_revoc_proof": null
					}
				],
				"aggregated_proof": {
					"c_hash": "95338200735084913599499055419155608196707840781756506869111197197201310736731",
					"c_list": [
						[
							2,
							42,
							111,
							14,
							231,
							203,
							164,
							154,
							61,
							135,
							95,
							7,
							158,
							233,
							155,
							158,
							122,
							217,
							102,
							25,
							138,
							110,
							205,
							69,
							204,
							255,
							225,
							223,
							14,
							26,
							155,
							200,
							39,
							191,
							250,
							42,
							240,
							80,
							166,
							213,
							132,
							145,
							63,
							86,
							21,
							80,
							83,
							24,
							209,
							183,
							157,
							53,
							91,
							25,
							241,
							168,
							59,
							181,
							89,
							255,
							51,
							92,
							88,
							251,
							105,
							77,
							50,
							80,
							78,
							133,
							124,
							115,
							79,
							161,
							252,
							57,
							54,
							68,
							62,
							116,
							225,
							209,
							57,
							237,
							169,
							155,
							14,
							143,
							122,
							175,
							59,
							225,
							166,
							125,
							83,
							202,
							196,
							107,
							219,
							19,
							23,
							180,
							199,
							231,
							130,
							78,
							203,
							191,
							65,
							95,
							78,
							42,
							97,
							252,
							39,
							103,
							15,
							174,
							228,
							39,
							131,
							199,
							200,
							91,
							253,
							64,
							170,
							93,
							156,
							115,
							11,
							22,
							107,
							168,
							85,
							235,
							100,
							188,
							102,
							78,
							253,
							179,
							131,
							43,
							22,
							106,
							112,
							221,
							159,
							205,
							125,
							117,
							239,
							87,
							201,
							3,
							95,
							145,
							55,
							1,
							69,
							230,
							5,
							227,
							145,
							69,
							107,
							55,
							179,
							220,
							231,
							19,
							6,
							30,
							141,
							135,
							96,
							186,
							189,
							196,
							191,
							13,
							69,
							102,
							97,
							117,
							23,
							167,
							0,
							207,
							233,
							209,
							7,
							235,
							101,
							248,
							58,
							91,
							117,
							56,
							148,
							103,
							116,
							115,
							79,
							88,
							251,
							227,
							242,
							11,
							158,
							207,
							11,
							171,
							195,
							91,
							6,
							154,
							1,
							187,
							74,
							188,
							111,
							52,
							158,
							139,
							26,
							143,
							161,
							140,
							19,
							117,
							21,
							35,
							65,
							194,
							41,
							89,
							153,
							136,
							143,
							177,
							54,
							34,
							225,
							76,
							40,
							210,
							186,
							239,
							161,
							235,
							157,
							144,
							92,
							86,
							117
						],
						[
							2,
							147,
							17,
							61,
							183,
							166,
							86,
							113,
							178,
							237,
							35,
							201,
							149,
							159,
							177,
							197,
							219,
							95,
							13,
							163,
							8,
							86,
							180,
							12,
							60,
							174,
							186,
							52,
							173,
							254,
							32,
							142,
							212,
							31,
							169,
							75,
							187,
							123,
							229,
							144,
							23,
							253,
							25,
							146,
							234,
							81,
							22,
							10,
							22,
							253,
							4,
							167,
							216,
							166,
							140,
							247,
							33,
							216,
							108,
							33,
							164,
							66,
							201,
							149,
							90,
							214,
							180,
							169,
							131,
							0,
							69,
							192,
							61,
							176,
							215,
							248,
							250,
							27,
							42,
							42,
							210,
							205,
							60,
							38,
							180,
							240,
							101,
							39,
							135,
							227,
							130,
							202,
							210,
							222,
							122,
							22,
							86,
							206,
							220,
							56,
							18,
							86,
							66,
							147,
							50,
							9,
							184,
							129,
							109,
							27,
							163,
							28,
							142,
							211,
							0,
							248,
							205,
							222,
							226,
							76,
							144,
							16,
							84,
							93,
							41,
							130,
							97,
							20,
							117,
							40,
							21,
							208,
							18,
							165,
							212,
							47,
							244,
							27,
							211,
							46,
							210,
							70,
							238,
							61,
							59,
							54,
							208,
							53,
							147,
							70,
							4,
							161,
							143,
							75,
							202,
							32,
							92,
							213,
							30,
							156,
							185,
							73,
							49,
							167,
							95,
							188,
							230,
							134,
							81,
							236,
							195,
							181,
							56,
							159,
							41,
							163,
							157,
							155,
							40,
							217,
							101,
							206,
							142,
							97,
							56,
							136,
							110,
							234,
							213,
							39,
							120,
							255,
							207,
							226,
							229,
							72,
							116,
							35,
							252,
							47,
							74,
							125,
							34,
							98,
							189,
							130,
							46,
							200,
							160,
							169,
							163,
							166,
							110,
							6,
							180,
							215,
							122,
							57,
							253,
							138,
							35,
							231,
							69,
							140,
							9,
							166,
							31,
							102,
							237,
							43,
							241,
							168,
							208,
							66,
							75,
							34,
							203,
							204,
							151,
							165,
							215,
							6,
							116,
							190,
							101,
							171,
							185,
							23,
							45,
							104,
							49,
							126,
							62,
							171,
							161,
							81,
							214
						],
						[
							212,
							8,
							2,
							118,
							128,
							168,
							179,
							99,
							136,
							133,
							117,
							125,
							90,
							148,
							10,
							16,
							237,
							109,
							143,
							202,
							122,
							132,
							102,
							59,
							173,
							69,
							14,
							13,
							108,
							68,
							55,
							50,
							28,
							75,
							79,
							42,
							82,
							17,
							18,
							37,
							230,
							127,
							42,
							122,
							196,
							26,
							110,
							152,
							173,
							196,
							224,
							239,
							26,
							82,
							184,
							221,
							242,
							247,
							24,
							72,
							94,
							83,
							122,
							240,
							85,
							217,
							35,
							248,
							58,
							145,
							200,
							32,
							68,
							96,
							97,
							73,
							83,
							147,
							140,
							151,
							76,
							177,
							91,
							18,
							214,
							118,
							31,
							92,
							139,
							232,
							188,
							204,
							127,
							175,
							143,
							177,
							205,
							1,
							27,
							83,
							24,
							228,
							30,
							2,
							189,
							8,
							240,
							95,
							188,
							210,
							67,
							59,
							127,
							4,
							211,
							94,
							237,
							144,
							56,
							243,
							107,
							35,
							72,
							79,
							249,
							173,
							222,
							34,
							80,
							228,
							38,
							134,
							152,
							49,
							181,
							123,
							39,
							105,
							202,
							169,
							117,
							93,
							213,
							194,
							138,
							47,
							230,
							139,
							255,
							4,
							125,
							135,
							89,
							246,
							221,
							161,
							152,
							73,
							192,
							12,
							232,
							54,
							232,
							191,
							210,
							238,
							254,
							12,
							177,
							125,
							96,
							168,
							196,
							144,
							89,
							207,
							171,
							4,
							195,
							234,
							68,
							253,
							119,
							207,
							67,
							232,
							202,
							144,
							10,
							6,
							236,
							194,
							218,
							39,
							104,
							89,
							21,
							128,
							129,
							44,
							124,
							90,
							201,
							123,
							0,
							210,
							83,
							251,
							239,
							45,
							30,
							181,
							140,
							65,
							62,
							177,
							55,
							104,
							190,
							228,
							181,
							228,
							44,
							3,
							158,
							231,
							50,
							6,
							104,
							140,
							172,
							255,
							215,
							103,
							79,
							157,
							57,
							99,
							62,
							222,
							101,
							147,
							247,
							165,
							111,
							185,
							83,
							17,
							138,
							30,
							253,
							37,
							142,
							4,
							5,
							200
						],
						[
							1,
							73,
							216,
							29,
							51,
							161,
							144,
							233,
							217,
							106,
							31,
							62,
							70,
							6,
							74,
							170,
							32,
							7,
							100,
							143,
							44,
							63,
							226,
							191,
							239,
							127,
							162,
							228,
							224,
							19,
							242,
							205,
							204,
							104,
							77,
							37,
							244,
							84,
							201,
							83,
							11,
							177,
							144,
							105,
							141,
							34,
							115,
							5,
							214,
							225,
							81,
							206,
							153,
							106,
							155,
							6,
							14,
							223,
							158,
							202,
							186,
							226,
							204,
							214,
							71,
							71,
							26,
							59,
							203,
							1,
							9,
							152,
							222,
							11,
							7,
							58,
							109,
							68,
							99,
							139,
							158,
							114,
							40,
							171,
							127,
							246,
							131,
							188,
							132,
							231,
							56,
							252,
							216,
							44,
							145,
							42,
							252,
							144,
							64,
							212,
							72,
							231,
							232,
							56,
							10,
							193,
							15,
							104,
							245,
							50,
							85,
							231,
							200,
							140,
							68,
							2,
							12,
							127,
							186,
							3,
							68,
							50,
							202,
							17,
							182,
							54,
							197,
							133,
							124,
							126,
							90,
							139,
							61,
							240,
							228,
							221,
							73,
							244,
							2,
							139,
							186,
							70,
							46,
							215,
							27,
							136,
							10,
							100,
							97,
							93,
							146,
							212,
							107,
							86,
							154,
							236,
							240,
							100,
							92,
							188,
							242,
							232,
							13,
							239,
							37,
							161,
							206,
							234,
							54,
							124,
							154,
							167,
							42,
							155,
							167,
							162,
							131,
							21,
							149,
							53,
							206,
							47,
							149,
							65,
							155,
							3,
							75,
							27,
							35,
							246,
							195,
							74,
							220,
							83,
							226,
							151,
							202,
							114,
							238,
							88,
							180,
							113,
							20,
							63,
							179,
							119,
							151,
							57,
							146,
							159,
							38,
							23,
							129,
							208,
							164,
							56,
							41,
							168,
							12,
							236,
							98,
							220,
							51,
							63,
							243,
							115,
							223,
							195,
							52,
							3,
							236,
							6,
							135,
							107,
							30,
							133,
							187,
							141,
							162,
							11,
							27,
							100,
							67,
							158,
							72,
							112,
							72,
							251,
							98,
							170,
							185,
							236,
							20,
							215,
							190,
							117,
							117
						],
						[
							1,
							123,
							38,
							113,
							48,
							24,
							203,
							220,
							46,
							167,
							198,
							69,
							172,
							112,
							10,
							251,
							101,
							254,
							123,
							234,
							19,
							183,
							39,
							173,
							216,
							93,
							124,
							80,
							171,
							32,
							223,
							234,
							161,
							58,
							208,
							63,
							77,
							150,
							171,
							81,
							202,
							179,
							83,
							191,
							55,
							30,
							202,
							151,
							39,
							16,
							32,
							119,
							145,
							82,
							177,
							244,
							11,
							252,
							111,
							47,
							230,
							124,
							251,
							127,
							150,
							72,
							146,
							161,
							237,
							155,
							108,
							161,
							30,
							86,
							17,
							185,
							6,
							9,
							94,
							89,
							14,
							248,
							223,
							244,
							177,
							203,
							4,
							99,
							24,
							85,
							6,
							135,
							16,
							66,
							251,
							30,
							119,
							64,
							161,
							217,
							163,
							107,
							102,
							159,
							210,
							221,
							220,
							240,
							127,
							146,
							138,
							129,
							222,
							13,
							170,
							175,
							79,
							50,
							68,
							153,
							147,
							105,
							103,
							176,
							119,
							77,
							208,
							101,
							249,
							226,
							225,
							84,
							146,
							78,
							22,
							16,
							138,
							53,
							51,
							73,
							210,
							138,
							220,
							146,
							210,
							208,
							90,
							137,
							212,
							149,
							184,
							3,
							139,
							13,
							48,
							205,
							142,
							168,
							151,
							194,
							59,
							63,
							193,
							103,
							6,
							181,
							100,
							141,
							190,
							233,
							7,
							96,
							226,
							234,
							224,
							131,
							226,
							248,
							197,
							183,
							15,
							20,
							217,
							243,
							151,
							161,
							0,
							235,
							6,
							110,
							222,
							167,
							144,
							14,
							238,
							26,
							123,
							189,
							228,
							105,
							121,
							191,
							190,
							65,
							109,
							101,
							47,
							141,
							171,
							248,
							199,
							41,
							14,
							116,
							136,
							183,
							101,
							135,
							239,
							2,
							227,
							219,
							9,
							82,
							110,
							244,
							74,
							108,
							48,
							50,
							181,
							10,
							219,
							227,
							255,
							196,
							92,
							57,
							149,
							218,
							80,
							135,
							97,
							255,
							70,
							209,
							208,
							102,
							108,
							189,
							79,
							10,
							19,
							25,
							237,
							152,
							145
						],
						[
							1,
							146,
							39,
							63,
							12,
							187,
							141,
							157,
							32,
							253,
							104,
							21,
							62,
							91,
							211,
							203,
							24,
							124,
							205,
							198,
							170,
							125,
							206,
							73,
							151,
							109,
							96,
							103,
							198,
							155,
							112,
							188,
							156,
							140,
							152,
							200,
							171,
							60,
							13,
							75,
							91,
							10,
							32,
							120,
							85,
							189,
							14,
							228,
							253,
							240,
							49,
							121,
							155,
							54,
							200,
							226,
							21,
							36,
							58,
							67,
							255,
							107,
							176,
							167,
							188,
							2,
							148,
							0,
							79,
							96,
							218,
							147,
							74,
							188,
							249,
							197,
							152,
							154,
							183,
							154,
							78,
							138,
							53,
							18,
							169,
							60,
							100,
							235,
							96,
							86,
							190,
							67,
							123,
							105,
							227,
							182,
							24,
							194,
							165,
							156,
							131,
							202,
							13,
							31,
							149,
							150,
							34,
							121,
							235,
							193,
							192,
							160,
							17,
							108,
							104,
							234,
							194,
							115,
							35,
							24,
							219,
							120,
							202,
							108,
							253,
							208,
							155,
							252,
							223,
							79,
							14,
							168,
							158,
							67,
							57,
							65,
							153,
							139,
							5,
							196,
							84,
							12,
							42,
							253,
							8,
							75,
							59,
							144,
							204,
							120,
							200,
							45,
							35,
							144,
							20,
							143,
							43,
							23,
							222,
							104,
							230,
							207,
							219,
							133,
							95,
							239,
							58,
							66,
							51,
							86,
							21,
							240,
							100,
							30,
							108,
							214,
							91,
							209,
							122,
							108,
							94,
							33,
							123,
							53,
							85,
							231,
							51,
							245,
							147,
							156,
							185,
							100,
							192,
							55,
							229,
							149,
							104,
							177,
							26,
							146,
							228,
							60,
							109,
							16,
							92,
							105,
							198,
							181,
							154,
							232,
							251,
							199,
							212,
							215,
							30,
							100,
							72,
							212,
							16,
							115,
							221,
							229,
							211,
							231,
							58,
							197,
							250,
							243,
							114,
							67,
							172,
							29,
							233,
							201,
							243,
							210,
							218,
							197,
							50,
							150,
							168,
							123,
							17,
							158,
							74,
							185,
							13,
							101,
							193,
							135,
							106,
							142,
							203,
							47,
							21,
							157,
							215
						]
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_proof": {
				"revealed_attrs": {
					"54bb4fa2-815a-4fd6-b190-e4e947920c95": {
						"sub_proof_index": 0,
						"raw": "John",
						"encoded": "76355713903561865866741292988746191972523015098789458240077478826513114743258"
					}
				},
				"self_attested_attrs": {},
				"unrevealed_attrs": {},
				"predicates": {
					"5986c749-67d9-4ed4-81fb-07870f2e54bd": {
						"sub_proof_index": 0
					}
				}
			},
			"identifiers": [
				{
					"schema_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:2:Schema 16113c6d-74ef-450e-9a1e-cd02abdfac6b:1.0",
					"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:151:default",
					"rev_reg_id": null,
					"timestamp": null
				}
			]
		}
	},
	"proposal": {
		"indy": {
			"name": "abc",
			"version": "1.0",
			"nonce": "33183147128480969412193",
			"requested_attributes": {
				"54bb4fa2-815a-4fd6-b190-e4e947920c95": {
					"name": "name",
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:151:default"
						}
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_predicates": {
				"5986c749-67d9-4ed4-81fb-07870f2e54bd": {
					"name": "age",
					"p_type": ">=",
					"p_value": 50,
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:151:default"
						}
					]
				}
			}
		}
	},
	"request": {
		"indy": {
			"name": "abc",
			"version": "1.0",
			"nonce": "604046010555332710545481",
			"requested_attributes": {
				"54bb4fa2-815a-4fd6-b190-e4e947920c95": {
					"name": "name",
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:151:default"
						}
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_predicates": {
				"5986c749-67d9-4ed4-81fb-07870f2e54bd": {
					"name": "age",
					"p_type": ">=",
					"p_value": 50,
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:151:default"
						}
					]
				}
			}
		}
	}
}

[TimoGlastra]

AnonCreds RS

{
	"presentation": {
		"indy": {
			"proof": {
				"proofs": [
					{
						"primary_proof": {
							"eq_proof": {
								"revealed_attrs": {
									"name": "76355713903561865866741292988746191972523015098789458240077478826513114743258"
								},
								"a_prime": "18983059119411378587103559493179627414827985532324773953077681373669692170561592050399414622038225672215321387747429616258528002482454316916207688887029846852162640249550241879403023159401890594372025929251305882416833478546503759150766631071612610104033595892997938719112631841785948834265797593319527354793849046367650721790978533479265802760827884841527108807577131787225301916924961366009385644783657480539160476555043167544599601515182672811735442411138061868726989675733408179229133479474037179187079596363754376315061808378086805806850858149716160265580928553991902542459166090861731121574317133269329464040005",
								"e": "90559320011200199273790769957704070309762854793607767784835353389883433715354047002884543545585070124565215567950563794665812302794645098",
								"v": "351108354426688498808840904206574449754015520067683019554274344567051647203896494123468324969919811590966853950937790597087667860557356151434295334536172771782952589985167405753788961423401273320543006851700633859121217687550749008795393611318290299735722989542879258125534881663359144339196146555551566419395646282998664004639749601889040520337052215727092786254932248795830303414623613295251538420125311762092689795340161983557879746755835982768201759017745534526053661692467633180434630597352263582126371931638976177965523921186173675143073684415533379710591108517390628865319292273820068984211242192750686903172558934853096418923973337595949442901739045054908790364144268361501324114455717308479913060915615059863985117552734926204925136120363527545427989230572586943523087380770816165414453108792134835084945411948565244996412670978474901968988030662678698160638846144543729927066870305637370920606864452881813409766",
								"m": {
									"image_0": "8173050292560914576123867757009738673459894344049897778387459633611965401034402360183723331539604193776178552810622610871494817870782111117866287817004285523428426211538843750764",
									"image_1": "1202963275979616983004617624350705963532340227831854484787052474330068189902714054000680345501014916476046614338434040222243668863406243246869294101648243208997412183511029921394",
									"age": "3609225825262335144256887531095192858426858642359137616851439964839105705361133452050300175169910603726308969535911997882782785883039759791452606125564495793924130896020990515451",
									"master_secret": "9475557725449206199662673426797616974111822294437553705432297576580761378794020286265397977276671815631625319478942503091685616256439529863715693627828150567595728354900219373673"
								},
								"m2": "353308278673176856132374377270900693087887270967199557903649049812811575249993485914823517704919078642863600771120137624217934425776646467956337720263457507646820549072906689969162200228165978493126402343455105163050423807219651839170236447041817983082187863714908607408726245097265790309753850758090498042865530529161627516098684132986277448506982377491843971984447306642271749271228743901251859699267699973292435324780049765370519726654633376163320736819183040923575666303647584818365536952006613552131003734470015650070151003799001016179322579115433385815815669473577948883928012531120156084458357961595512905916111449884718165974096250121674670572691178206302090370362496817447551263775486238389079981458830810733779404356591164"
							},
							"ge_proofs": []
						},
						"non_revoc_proof": null
					},
					{
						"primary_proof": {
							"eq_proof": {
								"revealed_attrs": {},
								"a_prime": "1533820930575653367553375129909074636115637435432939584968978126618744790764570421649489573043589900771300806400664110203166524066191921204660155315474663314123563547096776662528004814872758691375044242309938665652836733255510159329811727809713062675672875296683332642563061186150768147761328472363823265558381832270032985896211117190017360505897999452680545278902801194037675697431202589824815651359735418833705357323292856826785014454069790310475717973005352741158022331835576542763806842649427193333361461198289621234103069499001348758742081422625795486841127895442301390229840838867831713590342241973788102311871",
								"e": "68730728472270485209426491119292211099710184274313809790480994766130973372725780111552210118988391597428067945479886882300793269502575552",
								"v": "506476039133778909166007985944525945017088006703405420953851351110470600211543638306678680970794275186354586497802182596495253577125411038942354128085589025994736337469371325648338361182744339630398423171411184681427061328132023242600401250377552061542464662420858376207924162596090928887760652601902445371500778378061821336881217713633041878518139888942975671221155525570415704573298266321596370888509306180180463004811224773021361270907572006989585983519550225078958893776048179589240477480419763266238831110170721068455471928592447623447496941130088585745400621481697959918806074580466873896744980171431391043834531115334793788406041658796741710197463215864762663844780747587060495189508978014871229586113636954766353132232658957062303982560966086162740544647197373792535690342829924874172773305419424526062965754909002001351868010475963882336224704142991039658167433596263046354167810273001482264167049876189863142927",
								"m": {
									"age": "9602036491031404342438532508584889611294920540216409415682064675962381761656997260005308432585031419726455209356839093815174049670307108796858551339758742772929671690751567447349",
									"image_1": "7732161778574372568961420667808975023940454182434060113431303874652354525904975437648941912530987032874732904808174125312776317174541365519215571737584036880079556248841121925791",
									"image_0": "11201253426884730845805612214880833356522289153432164250965261869734175127780890208408232113988205182649536104056432501547834606296027563623495721914334007989072052636946154954081",
									"name": "13163422870250665730853433895325580559205194035290041037201095970893926117446637098390576518710474901072973052711580688552836818235005653716280412744482761029204923023683749739813",
									"master_secret": "9475557725449206199662673426797616974111822294437553705432297576580761378794020286265397977276671815631625319478942503091685616256439529863715693627828150567595728354900219373673"
								},
								"m2": "681673695374605409484012779236543525133002715441272342114397462183155015408894567055815819800727612980968901660891787219908913065916335040582044131054154821729314583730208208497070541013200602630912373175135595058824757604966334436923506623565359342237336325656349454861346349578983019613989302420787725034648776283853308220714515814930072736671928842578322415737397490805321721038535615428463466553349867795111147776240585848367331574326966885500134561456383696507688515244422066264370505365035862227178066465626539480555022040532570377210424215441227327230041715529931695431470464505870322734965253546323464471159734624153313205197459541359434479242520397535434419896051010750675517427000830445621639920437713305176176179629152601"
							},
							"ge_proofs": [
								{
									"u": {
										"0": "8552750589993918424789762694682567592018397547393513190979651773477199337606923216201862215735602467113834139880300451157479131456442465182762683359064915982810922539301902431178",
										"1": "4779569970368628023198512308770960103248910487759605136743961958534337355503222097717554300175704406139917836030007777701955778013074971269427869861022433940053131833792263812204",
										"2": "3730848771289191042706505540805743449497170943711600907526955637771914585096917693851515184082268937409424867684230025932546605416685658673480130844044843889596662328915905085501",
										"3": "10818086458179512638283148611565066515033666511778408597643646844829034042620798387970564964699343156977908578636550519296147804584726226998045819475545269516140552290720689289334"
									},
									"r": {
										"0": "1181059179401960645763596108105050008687088671040886128682203790635348924445297864101299080795312219076253679952655070293632849146652613502825183526603747225309875308016919383357133286933031060877635359559082303198649833433809539960474435548639160773558539243726733094964616609878423434678081833840288530445171452947401269690532908396206982106344312011856451773632905326984897833246135002246414195366849094347648554822324825414824858825058092215701317104770478197619733979309856747145948155612279747899636128098324488569508299717744132682038116601077106089044980894276150418850240042568544550519819131580563550423086483073429326992636440793573429110617979379865362593357648733367793729416135052656317481540932627138147",
										"1": "1605846018933262128235424481451088539795738818740429979160224892876822572960628736880521035651357858396800869079075985658741818114226572287287646520913331690914332964656733171579198758296764065541065474063103144889543907137975361127303776537200287491213420350074223190483544426148207313558074718954426253080725528650090712700906344224768184495796278838604557530901533004861801069110222386292015680277443337951194592738400661074827638735771779264181349830078352269134301073662102426437368079670677462003245832799893714121322727507488131665519918720581177212550028289571641218453788200076870253623279522497003291779199796889234476679765213934017126210773108711628694016662948925053856627626567907218777411306565583821137",
										"2": "452409719774433248287407828611503256906070895411835415986525586043655416817584666344194439648809458980691645614415665682881393927471688994120088174053900923171024482721803587089273355872424315469145445921569903241997817340170640046488441103383116013070531041325597975981637034059723714690216476942722462731594288541659224540380304056947762666663668023710204700729891223032826150863299815574624372601646853766647948734399133041974050339849877628426017289172295241445132012567688722081210809313774708936847567995709445779340525245870525462947997017781871864039097187311761620080679020309499822036416991517210117808252602441153781547018206950798913939041980297013160253829958338446238679444343074278720101938301894839748",
										"3": "889981832464339587810584035003295788763567327936201020527089227699010413772801445934405327665568864320937063317455982148211135761207208940574709198929432936692315577008890427414851518216456128304314177068420811338127108109861922006273715985970693768828940348865395185428760207426843863594810898939602512345129689025145989426198192430134488172499452833343251114577695871166986481200814105205207063947593306899192254186870215373138093891246031591511605866050347672484059235349060564979553665888629882291335080907549403599117629232760087175953055148719596680699567287107111391910179156328972953841040518894676924411598476288212774098996538589156002265796725937115155863701727881200316840819354029667220290148306329437066",
										"DELTA": "742898916619200544621002841261173951675170905253771445228896405520157294467590109730891216338783223119426726001798587625898531685952408418651444565275560578220688260201954516414488983779731431822191725768286111898287118725088609692176209548416805359055689036451167141837746090216414782297813487374254807610207038710421892479821489447808961484530756910994011496504013152131924681256115242238916934864252637467028618138818897549328196568528717283330957817564457513024170075581845808595161802202564613633812598088763744482791528840052322064940873647052650983304499836861699279051729574181272292464800799265221779265153559117521716906119201774239009670721664215256415697960120733827978241430048086769907387429557732836530"
									},
									"mj": "9602036491031404342438532508584889611294920540216409415682064675962381761656997260005308432585031419726455209356839093815174049670307108796858551339758742772929671690751567447349",
									"alpha": "6559552840071585439710576150717229599878803638655803967402007529210382235680000502188190415949466522223122449458351151787401308879545961028292728642988377428421192054069450822581693038749312119324875939833711603760343771887061785075656206552382665684265182779327709769793382691739365685886415842499425923220452613717474179449941586860300667746894636327811731553913492432814105516015754362195562921414419983387692497977329144958791420282777163251028302581442627943277179808402792305524069731496527692346709535233544265321284124184655093791484907225359654808733607678694895389197167214643051789112095548892532474074695683622606144351895437204965445925115942497305949328950805952078239421995036945981747879648034081590449850346252964291508940797952543192633835424430748583673239236456648350734297295048532831067385589602453123975599360937909",
									"t": {
										"0": "37934521727217398206623065584733775561586615835823452373102875602395717490060760386373198411324877860364904240299937758491961946703693125434689921041526558872274272349326393165874033592436489756992725248051744893120134216950521728783116383429985485316635466721244892705384984151484646755513422167818972731497199488364279535934182796728780918000851876439511426260293827851962467250932549073351989743074249014874697056795987763734713134888185179196599312482483960856841648528724617038122116876404474024031628415333126208008359270468436190226846727288309038368404885813920301000976362820422804466691860691925096712310917",
										"1": "64427180944385181787870872554528968150388675515351295640856826431754072341759413300822325138527005837248190545440164285842505098633007935309410916277273942719744198472420675030977111901156852198760568432087458795302344110764908691915645871435536094353780389762789054535189618828920450006134036979837462953350033308944300721729902239383739066096897319336157428248874416206591270307553349140801480339268115063532520515623900386740088611368019825413869436240656346776243458130757290321227868553385853960526456256901755343685888983756324350242974942524564012942819882399202444597815710085567904902640862876756548708068207",
										"2": "42269371500135387531184835448547174949100568333243734801692687487936837584484615727914728627863513020740104120121952514642727541085254069084198965035969209941984983192466844569005779039705408769456033873682995027761185143398763129085137621497881029131488457979633955397726022767692417934442294908260698997892297233207271791535063629019357013366173866134151774857708904454594520288117511324384777320787163005039480595534588777232725470017922201913811054003578495897387985129178831667355578776095369829821434630811873504641321117904544614086426835720482745886444204314848113522597350228835436305728101636470784936587964",
										"3": "79762452755745781202451234220780409278957135469289018741123438895819760731092166979840399896232784294570864714919488123947165669216611166399758049681955251170784643563882264100987340872930627167656566593147370768457528255490503316447358905166368239569567084625623801622347437404319604729980208032162273444313149568423180112884349239255579552496282055903164138951004412569793542004884740601453911492764719184979199724773380146613412706690367708338138166007782348968872377052692023928142285942722672546490790463818551502495561409380765431359651064514768742531605491050674434041957206619636642049242251514259783708085382",
										"DELTA": "33695048733672538494834612956050601463786010078334414649702179848710149113059467741473375229734642866327496835160055319952544040309911667306927018046219791361400258112158945630106487794883898563205659671537152948481506247932514561328630139374250025680005397346439208568157939023886671251410069609534615272445993565754133845409474782231108314655723104913210348039610526869583394166302813256781271999913327661439178430074469838701774198661530477854969540322268290117512066586321292021915756350991211979661062560242907528390702675391157756123090835356867311571773257263943368197049009156377355593043187362844718120467553"
									},
									"predicate": {
										"attr_name": "age",
										"p_type": "GE",
										"value": 50
									}
								}
							]
						},
						"non_revoc_proof": null
					}
				],
				"aggregated_proof": {
					"c_hash": "41542125904382235540347762915738768496452592788051909707570822828530207061969",
					"c_list": [
						[
							150,
							95,
							242,
							129,
							234,
							240,
							250,
							117,
							108,
							69,
							29,
							168,
							213,
							111,
							94,
							129,
							231,
							41,
							229,
							66,
							192,
							130,
							40,
							230,
							108,
							51,
							238,
							18,
							196,
							91,
							220,
							189,
							67,
							32,
							172,
							25,
							40,
							73,
							243,
							19,
							188,
							219,
							129,
							164,
							170,
							254,
							48,
							213,
							250,
							8,
							222,
							236,
							17,
							66,
							135,
							76,
							70,
							225,
							79,
							103,
							120,
							93,
							53,
							229,
							152,
							236,
							57,
							151,
							187,
							34,
							39,
							164,
							86,
							108,
							108,
							16,
							28,
							7,
							163,
							16,
							6,
							92,
							109,
							25,
							62,
							67,
							214,
							215,
							115,
							50,
							176,
							98,
							51,
							57,
							32,
							222,
							248,
							220,
							213,
							10,
							203,
							8,
							115,
							226,
							118,
							91,
							94,
							229,
							233,
							245,
							130,
							220,
							79,
							177,
							35,
							69,
							229,
							194,
							41,
							0,
							64,
							77,
							193,
							20,
							196,
							147,
							28,
							171,
							203,
							33,
							112,
							155,
							185,
							18,
							161,
							27,
							221,
							255,
							235,
							99,
							149,
							251,
							254,
							191,
							183,
							161,
							42,
							227,
							117,
							85,
							214,
							252,
							119,
							239,
							76,
							11,
							43,
							69,
							184,
							33,
							40,
							70,
							57,
							231,
							43,
							107,
							74,
							132,
							13,
							170,
							92,
							145,
							13,
							188,
							69,
							140,
							234,
							80,
							139,
							234,
							152,
							128,
							50,
							187,
							29,
							191,
							248,
							112,
							148,
							45,
							13,
							106,
							221,
							238,
							12,
							240,
							198,
							247,
							230,
							108,
							78,
							22,
							144,
							182,
							130,
							244,
							139,
							127,
							134,
							235,
							134,
							245,
							250,
							48,
							92,
							13,
							84,
							40,
							163,
							89,
							223,
							174,
							47,
							147,
							232,
							236,
							170,
							86,
							130,
							108,
							235,
							221,
							222,
							40,
							84,
							135,
							92,
							173,
							124,
							10,
							104,
							52,
							196,
							71,
							159,
							100,
							161,
							148,
							243,
							125,
							66,
							88,
							4,
							188,
							154,
							69
						],
						[
							12,
							38,
							115,
							166,
							187,
							199,
							64,
							112,
							97,
							140,
							55,
							204,
							41,
							82,
							21,
							90,
							58,
							92,
							105,
							226,
							89,
							175,
							67,
							63,
							57,
							171,
							86,
							206,
							178,
							56,
							164,
							3,
							65,
							241,
							154,
							245,
							0,
							120,
							73,
							83,
							23,
							229,
							74,
							105,
							71,
							180,
							33,
							20,
							210,
							187,
							161,
							152,
							115,
							187,
							166,
							196,
							192,
							217,
							252,
							25,
							110,
							55,
							71,
							253,
							58,
							241,
							149,
							194,
							238,
							214,
							225,
							16,
							14,
							63,
							171,
							229,
							231,
							104,
							71,
							160,
							94,
							135,
							47,
							87,
							229,
							41,
							226,
							107,
							32,
							164,
							255,
							205,
							41,
							87,
							123,
							237,
							174,
							215,
							239,
							189,
							10,
							216,
							144,
							116,
							213,
							36,
							135,
							73,
							129,
							63,
							192,
							102,
							187,
							22,
							112,
							98,
							143,
							56,
							133,
							62,
							32,
							65,
							121,
							151,
							50,
							115,
							45,
							8,
							90,
							45,
							64,
							80,
							161,
							222,
							126,
							125,
							78,
							188,
							11,
							224,
							44,
							190,
							28,
							253,
							162,
							147,
							185,
							250,
							60,
							235,
							150,
							7,
							170,
							67,
							218,
							212,
							49,
							109,
							190,
							79,
							128,
							204,
							81,
							185,
							34,
							48,
							150,
							120,
							149,
							83,
							41,
							37,
							114,
							215,
							70,
							224,
							29,
							104,
							224,
							231,
							173,
							214,
							7,
							230,
							57,
							14,
							226,
							77,
							40,
							196,
							64,
							108,
							7,
							188,
							107,
							33,
							46,
							139,
							41,
							242,
							63,
							8,
							53,
							5,
							95,
							189,
							234,
							100,
							191,
							249,
							44,
							178,
							172,
							229,
							144,
							90,
							223,
							141,
							8,
							149,
							141,
							200,
							21,
							214,
							239,
							25,
							87,
							193,
							146,
							175,
							69,
							228,
							246,
							163,
							127,
							245,
							134,
							145,
							181,
							166,
							226,
							152,
							158,
							163,
							180,
							96,
							103,
							146,
							83,
							154,
							203,
							134,
							202,
							35,
							63,
							191
						],
						[
							1,
							44,
							127,
							209,
							215,
							21,
							71,
							97,
							69,
							101,
							253,
							80,
							70,
							173,
							142,
							79,
							128,
							111,
							250,
							210,
							235,
							98,
							92,
							55,
							158,
							66,
							143,
							2,
							203,
							211,
							128,
							85,
							151,
							138,
							80,
							84,
							228,
							151,
							12,
							243,
							190,
							91,
							140,
							9,
							8,
							217,
							50,
							9,
							83,
							121,
							123,
							242,
							247,
							176,
							29,
							239,
							11,
							155,
							204,
							3,
							116,
							248,
							255,
							113,
							118,
							120,
							234,
							181,
							94,
							49,
							6,
							123,
							184,
							18,
							186,
							202,
							237,
							231,
							230,
							64,
							234,
							109,
							147,
							194,
							66,
							129,
							85,
							118,
							91,
							26,
							8,
							126,
							127,
							241,
							168,
							85,
							12,
							3,
							82,
							203,
							1,
							60,
							23,
							45,
							146,
							81,
							52,
							71,
							0,
							31,
							142,
							137,
							172,
							252,
							177,
							33,
							74,
							146,
							73,
							157,
							143,
							27,
							25,
							19,
							132,
							50,
							199,
							99,
							202,
							146,
							83,
							251,
							132,
							238,
							133,
							26,
							208,
							24,
							234,
							212,
							241,
							137,
							66,
							91,
							26,
							128,
							68,
							110,
							2,
							203,
							239,
							19,
							177,
							237,
							90,
							220,
							172,
							127,
							70,
							167,
							14,
							230,
							158,
							242,
							38,
							222,
							102,
							123,
							230,
							222,
							112,
							255,
							213,
							153,
							68,
							145,
							161,
							79,
							203,
							63,
							135,
							163,
							221,
							48,
							31,
							172,
							247,
							196,
							197,
							154,
							135,
							103,
							122,
							199,
							248,
							209,
							191,
							245,
							187,
							231,
							27,
							209,
							79,
							161,
							46,
							157,
							78,
							116,
							20,
							140,
							251,
							144,
							238,
							123,
							30,
							188,
							206,
							39,
							98,
							12,
							139,
							242,
							106,
							127,
							116,
							179,
							150,
							20,
							59,
							22,
							137,
							133,
							24,
							168,
							36,
							138,
							88,
							163,
							12,
							168,
							225,
							220,
							151,
							216,
							75,
							25,
							64,
							113,
							117,
							230,
							218,
							111,
							121,
							16,
							135,
							16,
							133
						],
						[
							1,
							254,
							92,
							144,
							151,
							189,
							192,
							221,
							78,
							184,
							106,
							37,
							228,
							100,
							29,
							2,
							193,
							18,
							25,
							4,
							213,
							28,
							134,
							76,
							184,
							159,
							93,
							18,
							66,
							133,
							43,
							190,
							64,
							50,
							246,
							179,
							183,
							195,
							0,
							15,
							177,
							165,
							10,
							92,
							228,
							152,
							150,
							131,
							251,
							208,
							146,
							89,
							137,
							32,
							106,
							20,
							149,
							60,
							234,
							132,
							240,
							129,
							165,
							10,
							174,
							147,
							126,
							214,
							130,
							250,
							219,
							1,
							116,
							201,
							46,
							164,
							217,
							2,
							143,
							119,
							81,
							55,
							1,
							127,
							170,
							234,
							170,
							42,
							75,
							131,
							66,
							79,
							26,
							162,
							33,
							78,
							63,
							17,
							125,
							239,
							63,
							12,
							31,
							211,
							115,
							184,
							46,
							109,
							241,
							30,
							26,
							239,
							69,
							141,
							210,
							194,
							173,
							49,
							252,
							66,
							46,
							49,
							81,
							117,
							38,
							206,
							190,
							49,
							154,
							90,
							55,
							61,
							117,
							104,
							216,
							31,
							6,
							15,
							30,
							33,
							198,
							84,
							14,
							18,
							52,
							185,
							103,
							88,
							28,
							58,
							199,
							70,
							226,
							164,
							182,
							232,
							253,
							165,
							174,
							115,
							83,
							249,
							140,
							175,
							177,
							32,
							213,
							23,
							186,
							4,
							212,
							185,
							106,
							3,
							96,
							119,
							169,
							185,
							137,
							37,
							113,
							100,
							40,
							75,
							181,
							178,
							89,
							122,
							58,
							15,
							168,
							218,
							141,
							112,
							105,
							86,
							201,
							132,
							232,
							249,
							118,
							80,
							199,
							129,
							206,
							61,
							42,
							18,
							184,
							10,
							111,
							45,
							218,
							66,
							154,
							81,
							230,
							196,
							203,
							142,
							3,
							98,
							114,
							65,
							81,
							139,
							8,
							88,
							109,
							163,
							32,
							180,
							106,
							86,
							55,
							44,
							206,
							167,
							10,
							175,
							94,
							51,
							129,
							241,
							232,
							133,
							135,
							23,
							143,
							230,
							7,
							73,
							104,
							8,
							245,
							235,
							111
						],
						[
							1,
							78,
							214,
							129,
							242,
							70,
							187,
							116,
							188,
							174,
							37,
							122,
							175,
							11,
							175,
							164,
							12,
							238,
							145,
							86,
							125,
							193,
							111,
							11,
							92,
							159,
							75,
							6,
							1,
							157,
							180,
							158,
							164,
							166,
							73,
							174,
							186,
							233,
							142,
							220,
							10,
							157,
							10,
							176,
							135,
							62,
							162,
							76,
							138,
							203,
							37,
							49,
							205,
							186,
							208,
							147,
							113,
							168,
							84,
							171,
							186,
							32,
							107,
							164,
							8,
							90,
							223,
							62,
							192,
							237,
							208,
							37,
							209,
							159,
							182,
							132,
							228,
							162,
							127,
							208,
							242,
							72,
							242,
							72,
							252,
							193,
							213,
							154,
							137,
							29,
							220,
							210,
							51,
							157,
							19,
							100,
							17,
							202,
							80,
							36,
							179,
							155,
							23,
							92,
							63,
							139,
							34,
							155,
							206,
							51,
							81,
							20,
							177,
							187,
							212,
							44,
							242,
							135,
							252,
							229,
							91,
							233,
							147,
							191,
							161,
							67,
							143,
							37,
							139,
							31,
							170,
							200,
							135,
							94,
							237,
							236,
							33,
							17,
							185,
							0,
							8,
							108,
							225,
							219,
							86,
							198,
							16,
							74,
							66,
							240,
							92,
							49,
							222,
							57,
							156,
							147,
							158,
							0,
							98,
							12,
							217,
							97,
							243,
							217,
							119,
							231,
							30,
							255,
							172,
							72,
							192,
							11,
							63,
							227,
							120,
							25,
							168,
							244,
							160,
							102,
							130,
							237,
							247,
							11,
							254,
							187,
							191,
							60,
							86,
							119,
							253,
							214,
							189,
							200,
							94,
							93,
							128,
							72,
							197,
							225,
							158,
							9,
							141,
							241,
							11,
							28,
							144,
							68,
							39,
							80,
							248,
							62,
							29,
							214,
							149,
							164,
							212,
							5,
							157,
							129,
							193,
							210,
							2,
							131,
							10,
							62,
							17,
							2,
							174,
							91,
							173,
							140,
							39,
							33,
							135,
							13,
							222,
							194,
							46,
							84,
							157,
							215,
							88,
							35,
							205,
							178,
							255,
							248,
							141,
							234,
							66,
							209,
							143,
							88,
							131,
							50,
							188
						],
						[
							2,
							119,
							215,
							32,
							30,
							176,
							212,
							151,
							32,
							152,
							57,
							74,
							25,
							139,
							243,
							193,
							167,
							97,
							143,
							63,
							9,
							104,
							218,
							240,
							226,
							124,
							64,
							228,
							101,
							33,
							74,
							210,
							21,
							71,
							191,
							19,
							149,
							141,
							53,
							239,
							67,
							141,
							148,
							231,
							42,
							81,
							158,
							141,
							35,
							42,
							9,
							191,
							80,
							226,
							27,
							205,
							206,
							242,
							108,
							152,
							204,
							113,
							110,
							137,
							170,
							156,
							68,
							190,
							181,
							144,
							128,
							30,
							209,
							139,
							63,
							27,
							200,
							176,
							120,
							154,
							37,
							99,
							10,
							172,
							236,
							158,
							127,
							146,
							119,
							17,
							137,
							189,
							25,
							179,
							95,
							214,
							6,
							235,
							104,
							116,
							242,
							89,
							111,
							79,
							9,
							203,
							106,
							81,
							72,
							203,
							199,
							172,
							204,
							98,
							194,
							60,
							28,
							128,
							252,
							35,
							208,
							169,
							232,
							102,
							207,
							184,
							86,
							9,
							216,
							12,
							216,
							56,
							106,
							100,
							156,
							107,
							226,
							120,
							209,
							73,
							190,
							176,
							174,
							140,
							222,
							247,
							138,
							192,
							230,
							47,
							177,
							110,
							30,
							114,
							210,
							88,
							248,
							11,
							36,
							228,
							236,
							53,
							22,
							134,
							16,
							78,
							130,
							172,
							181,
							212,
							139,
							253,
							174,
							75,
							5,
							134,
							172,
							186,
							5,
							47,
							115,
							241,
							84,
							91,
							74,
							227,
							92,
							134,
							54,
							71,
							190,
							62,
							223,
							93,
							179,
							21,
							238,
							49,
							175,
							118,
							121,
							55,
							237,
							96,
							174,
							61,
							210,
							235,
							211,
							219,
							199,
							32,
							249,
							119,
							136,
							90,
							122,
							112,
							123,
							115,
							15,
							214,
							6,
							87,
							196,
							155,
							238,
							169,
							178,
							234,
							219,
							153,
							10,
							125,
							243,
							212,
							39,
							221,
							243,
							68,
							95,
							219,
							186,
							65,
							100,
							33,
							198,
							151,
							209,
							195,
							18,
							144,
							124,
							165,
							124,
							140,
							134
						],
						[
							1,
							10,
							234,
							140,
							31,
							159,
							218,
							146,
							109,
							93,
							14,
							134,
							160,
							156,
							236,
							48,
							137,
							35,
							194,
							55,
							180,
							18,
							133,
							121,
							47,
							196,
							194,
							20,
							221,
							234,
							129,
							32,
							1,
							248,
							216,
							145,
							58,
							132,
							56,
							0,
							152,
							169,
							20,
							93,
							96,
							122,
							90,
							205,
							226,
							10,
							162,
							125,
							198,
							216,
							159,
							89,
							121,
							250,
							234,
							95,
							192,
							195,
							71,
							176,
							171,
							147,
							83,
							109,
							209,
							52,
							106,
							223,
							85,
							31,
							69,
							249,
							118,
							250,
							110,
							122,
							216,
							12,
							94,
							93,
							83,
							199,
							235,
							172,
							235,
							130,
							203,
							205,
							27,
							61,
							126,
							246,
							180,
							23,
							189,
							63,
							120,
							171,
							231,
							5,
							255,
							219,
							63,
							128,
							3,
							120,
							178,
							116,
							79,
							28,
							208,
							40,
							115,
							179,
							53,
							248,
							234,
							221,
							67,
							202,
							204,
							130,
							50,
							255,
							225,
							168,
							167,
							235,
							64,
							19,
							177,
							213,
							16,
							254,
							200,
							0,
							236,
							14,
							5,
							191,
							63,
							145,
							198,
							28,
							84,
							156,
							216,
							39,
							86,
							22,
							184,
							130,
							35,
							241,
							185,
							254,
							161,
							21,
							86,
							91,
							24,
							59,
							204,
							240,
							190,
							205,
							146,
							210,
							135,
							202,
							13,
							92,
							127,
							236,
							114,
							75,
							176,
							0,
							115,
							135,
							216,
							2,
							23,
							65,
							113,
							196,
							151,
							102,
							143,
							5,
							255,
							178,
							222,
							107,
							166,
							226,
							251,
							141,
							106,
							9,
							148,
							173,
							102,
							31,
							108,
							200,
							44,
							57,
							65,
							43,
							37,
							33,
							251,
							42,
							255,
							133,
							186,
							238,
							194,
							13,
							79,
							76,
							199,
							128,
							196,
							130,
							101,
							30,
							37,
							53,
							68,
							217,
							37,
							143,
							19,
							64,
							52,
							7,
							153,
							165,
							196,
							5,
							174,
							64,
							24,
							239,
							198,
							179,
							216,
							216,
							30,
							124,
							97
						]
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_proof": {
				"revealed_attrs": {
					"9328cb16-87ce-43ef-919b-5828fa78c5b3": {
						"sub_proof_index": 0,
						"raw": "John",
						"encoded": "76355713903561865866741292988746191972523015098789458240077478826513114743258"
					}
				},
				"self_attested_attrs": {},
				"unrevealed_attrs": {},
				"predicates": {
					"fe00fb7e-7c81-4503-a08e-a165677582e0": {
						"sub_proof_index": 1
					}
				}
			},
			"identifiers": [
				{
					"schema_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:2:Schema b8e0561e-ecec-4716-9348-144fead3899b:1.0",
					"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default",
					"rev_reg_id": null,
					"timestamp": null
				},
				{
					"schema_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:2:Schema b8e0561e-ecec-4716-9348-144fead3899b:1.0",
					"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default",
					"rev_reg_id": null,
					"timestamp": null
				}
			]
		}
	},
	"proposal": {
		"indy": {
			"name": "abc",
			"version": "1.0",
			"nonce": "897121486743992994844143",
			"requested_attributes": {
				"9328cb16-87ce-43ef-919b-5828fa78c5b3": {
					"name": "name",
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default"
						}
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_predicates": {
				"fe00fb7e-7c81-4503-a08e-a165677582e0": {
					"name": "age",
					"p_type": ">=",
					"p_value": 50,
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default"
						}
					]
				}
			}
		}
	},
	"request": {
		"indy": {
			"name": "abc",
			"version": "1.0",
			"nonce": "480899713111471099219873",
			"requested_attributes": {
				"9328cb16-87ce-43ef-919b-5828fa78c5b3": {
					"name": "name",
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default"
						}
					]
				}
			},
			"requested_predicates": {
				"fe00fb7e-7c81-4503-a08e-a165677582e0": {
					"name": "age",
					"p_type": ">=",
					"p_value": 50,
					"restrictions": [
						{
							"cred_def_id": "TL1EaPFCZ8Si5aUrqScBDt:3:CL:147:default"
						}
					]
				}
			}
		}
	}
}

[swcurran]

I see the eq, ge and aggregated in both, so the proofs themselves are the same. I see that the primary_proofs element is presented differently. Anything else?

It’s hard to see all the differences in trying to scan the presentations. Any more details on the difference you are calling out.

Note that the Indy SDK still relies on Ursa, which has been archived. Changes have been made to AnonCreds to improve since the cl-signatures crate was moved out of Ursa. As such, it is not surprising that the indy-sdk is falling behind.

[TimoGlastra]

Maybe we can discuss this during the WG call later today?

[swcurran]

Thanks for bringing this up again @TimoGlastra — the difference that you note is not what I had expected. @andrewwhitehead is going to take a look.

The presentation has one source credential used to share one revealed value and one predicate. That should be mean there is (as in the indy-sdk case) one eq_proof for the revealed value, and one ge_proofs entry for the predicate. If there were more predicates, there would be more ge_proofs entries (which should be called ne_proofs as in “not equal”). As Timo notes, in the AnonCreds RS case, there are two primary proofs, one with the eq_proof for the revealed value, and then a second with both an eq_proof (but this time with no revealed values), and the predicate ge_proofs.

TBD why the change, but at this point it appears to be unexpected.

[andrewwhitehead]

Essentially in the anoncreds case (either in AFJ or anoncreds-rs, I'm not sure which yet), the same credential is being referenced separately for the attribute reveal and the predicate. I can reproduce the behaviour in the indy-credx Python wrapper by copying the source credential before adding it to the PresentCredentials structure:

present_creds = PresentCredentials()
present_creds.add_attributes(
    cred_received, "test_eq", reveal=True,
)
present_creds.add_predicates(
    cred_received, "test_ge",
)
presentation = Presentation.create(
    pres_req, present_creds, {}, link_secret, [schema], [cred_def]
)

vs.

present_creds = PresentCredentials()
present_creds.add_attributes(
    cred_received, "test_eq", reveal=True,
)
cred_copy = cred_received.copy()
present_creds.add_predicates(
    cred_copy, "test_ge",
)
presentation = Presentation.create(
    pres_req, present_creds, {}, link_secret, [schema], [cred_def]
)

[TimoGlastra]

Ah interesting. Yeah we have some auto-serialization logic to make it easier to work with the wrapper, but it probably encodes all objects separaetly to a native object.

As an optimization we should probably check whether some objects are equal, and then create the same cred instance for them (although that can lead to issues with not knowing when we can dispose of the object).

However, I think AnonCreds RS could also just look at equality of e.g. signatures to see if the credentials are the same (or the id or something).

This does make me curious whether there's a simple way for someone to check this. At least in AFJ we verify the proof and then we return which attributes/predicates were shared for which group, but as the predicates and attributes are from separate groups, if you just look at the revealed_attrs and revealed_predicates and revealed_attr_groups you won't be able to see whether a predicate and attribute group are from the same credential?

Is this something that we should add a check for? There's not really a way to indicate this requirement in a proof request, so it's up to the user then to decide whether or not to do this (It's valid I think to say I want name and age from the same credential, but for age I only want to know it's >18. Indy SDK seems to create a valid proof in this case, but it's also fine if it is created as two proofs, as we don't request it being from the same cred).

Should AnonCreds request allow to specify that predicate and attribute request groups can be linked to each other to indicate the values must come from the same cred?

For AnonCreds with DIF PE this will actually be possible as we can combine predicates and attribute requirements into a single input descriptor, which should result in a single credential. Then we would have to do some manual processing of the submitted proof to check whether the predicates and attributes are actually submitted within the same proof and not as two separate proofs (as a malicious user could use that to combine two credentials then?)

[andrewwhitehead]

Looking at the AFJ code, it does already dedupe the credentials as it is loading them (by credential ID), but then it adds separate entries for each attribute and predicate here, and I think that logic can be easily updated: https://github.com/openwallet-foundation/agent-framework-javascript/blob/main/packages/anoncreds-rs/src/services/AnonCredsRsHolderService.ts#L147-L159

It would be great to have better ways to specify that attributes and predicates are meant to be from the same credential. Initially there was no support for that, and BC worked with Evernym to get the 'names' property supported for requested attributes, which does allow for attributes (but not predicates) to be grouped.

[swcurran]

Per @andrewwhitehead ’s note, it looks like this is an AFJ issue, not an AnonCreds RS issue, correct? As such, and we leave it to the AFJ team, @TimoGlastra ?

Thanks!

[TimoGlastra]

Well yes we can 'fix' this in AFJ, but I don't think it will matter very much to most people using AnonCreds

As you would have to manually inspect the submitted proof for this to be verified, as AnonCreds lib will allow both proofs

Make we don't want to extend AnonCreds further, but maybe could add an optional ref id or something to make it so that two groups must come from the same cred? That's mostly in the proof request then and the final proof check.

This would also be useful for pex support as you can request multiple attributes + multiple predicates in a single input descriptor.

[TimoGlastra]

cc @2mau we're going to have to manually check that a credential submitted in PEX if it has multiple attributes/predicates they're all from the same proof (and thus cred).