[BUG] Stuck `waiting for stream` with Firefox (Android)

[bryan065]

Is there an existing issue for this?

• I have searched the existing issues

Current Behavior

Connecting to webtop via https://server:3002 (changed from default port) will load a blank page with the Selkies control on the left and be stuck.waiting for stream.

Tested using Firefox for Android and the Fennic fork of Firefox. Loads fine with JPEG.

Edit: just tested with Firefox desktop (Windows) and it is working so seems like a Firefox for Android issue?

Tested with Debian and Alpine. With Nvidia GPU enabled/disabled. With default user:group. With fresh images and volumes.

No issues with the same Docker config in Chrome (Android)

Found an issue related to this here:
selkies-project/selkies#18

Expected Behavior

RTSP stream loads successfully

Steps To Reproduce

Use Firefox

Environment

- OS: Debian Bookworm (OpenMediaVault)
- How docker service was installed: OpenMediaVault plugin (essentially just uses the packagemanager)

CPU architecture

x86-64

Docker creation

services:
  webtop:
    image: lscr.io/linuxserver/webtop:debian-xfce
    #image: lscr.io/linuxserver/webtop:debian-kde
    container_name: webtop
    security_opt:
      - seccomp:unconfined #optional
    deploy:
      resources:
        reservations:
          devices:
            - driver: nvidia
              capabilities: [gpu]
    environment:
      - PUID=1001
      - PGID=100
      - TZ=$TIMEZONE
      - SUBFOLDER=/ #optional
      - TITLE=Webtop #optional
      - CUSTOM_USER=bryan
      - PASSWORD=${password}
      #- DOCKER_MODS=linuxserver/mods:universal-package-install
      #- INSTALL_PACKAGES=fonts-noto-cjk|vlc|7zip
    volumes:
      - $DOCKER_CONFIG_PATH/webtop-new2:/config
      #- /var/run/docker.sock:/var/run/docker.sock #optional
    ports:
      - 3000:3000
      - 3002:3001
    #devices:
     # - /dev/dri:/dev/dri #optional
    shm_size: "1gb" #optional
    restart: unless-stopped

Container logs

Tried to paste logs but field cannot be longer than 65536 characters?

webtop_logs.txt

[github-actions]

Thanks for opening your first issue here! Be sure to follow the relevant issue templates, or risk having this issue marked as invalid.

[thelamer]

Yes it is likely that that mobile browser lacks webcodecs support, also firefoxe's implementation of webcodecs is not as fast as chromiums, just in general use a chromium based browser as a client.

[thefaboss]

Hi there,
I've juste got the same issue but on 2 different computers with different browsers on Windows 11 : firefox and vivaldi (chromium).
Both of them are up to date.

[thelamer]

Hi there, I've juste got the same issue but on 2 different computers with different browsers on Windows 11 : firefox and vivaldi (chromium). Both of them are up to date.

I am interested if chrome/chromium works or edge on your system.

[thefaboss]

Same issue with edge and chrome :\

[thelamer]

Same issue with edge and chrome :\

I need more, system setup video card etc also try running chromium with --disable-gpu, all of these browsers work on my Windows 11 installation.

[thefaboss]

Still the same disabling gpu on my browsers...

May be the issue is on the server side ?
Here what I get when I launch the image :

docker compose up

[+] Running 1/1
 ✔ Container webtop  Recreated                                                                                                                                                       1.8s 
Attaching to webtop
webtop  | [migrations] started
webtop  | [migrations] no migrations found
webtop  | ───────────────────────────────────────
webtop  | 
webtop  |       ██╗     ███████╗██╗ ██████╗
webtop  |       ██║     ██╔════╝██║██╔═══██╗
webtop  |       ██║     ███████╗██║██║   ██║
webtop  |       ██║     ╚════██║██║██║   ██║
webtop  |       ███████╗███████║██║╚██████╔╝
webtop  |       ╚══════╝╚══════╝╚═╝ ╚═════╝
webtop  | 
webtop  |    Brought to you by linuxserver.io
webtop  | ───────────────────────────────────────
webtop  | 
webtop  | To support LSIO projects visit:
webtop  | https://www.linuxserver.io/donate/
webtop  | 
webtop  | ───────────────────────────────────────
webtop  | GID/UID
webtop  | ───────────────────────────────────────
webtop  | 
webtop  | User UID:    1000
webtop  | User GID:    1000
webtop  | ───────────────────────────────────────
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/js0: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/js1: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/js2: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/js3: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/event1000: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/event1001: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/event1002: Operation not permitted
webtop  | mknod: /dev/input/event1003: Operation not permitted
webtop  | chmod: cannot access '/dev/input/js*': No such file or directory
webtop  | chmod: cannot access '/dev/input/event*': No such file or directory
webtop  | [custom-init] No custom files found, skipping...
webtop  | Can't open display :1
webtop  | _XSERVTransmkdir: ERROR: euid != 0,directory /tmp/.X11-unix will not be created.
webtop  | screen 0 shmid 0
webtop  | [ls.io-init] done.
webtop  | xrandr: cannot find mode "1024x768"
webtop  | xrandr: cannot find mode 1024x768
webtop  | 19
webtop  | 20
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:pixelflux library found. Striped encoding modes available.
webtop  | INFO:root:Expected C js_config_t size (from ctypes): 1354 bytes
webtop  | INFO:main:Upload directory ensured: /config/Desktop
webtop  | INFO:main:Starting Selkies GStreamer (WebSocket Mode) with args: Namespace(encoder='x264enc', framerate=60, video_bitrate=16000, h264_crf=25, h264_fullcolor=False, debug=False)
webtop  | INFO:main:Initial Encoder: x264enc, Framerate: 60, Bitrate: 16000kbps
webtop  | INFO:main:GSTStreamingApp initialized: encoder=x264enc, display=1024x768
webtop  | INFO:main:All main components initialized. Running server...
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Resetting keyboard modifiers.
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Initializing 4 persistent gamepad instances...
webtop  | INFO:root:Packed js_config payload for 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad' (js0): len=1360 bytes. Name='Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', Vendor=0x045e, Product=0x028e, Version=0x0100, Reported Buttons=13 (Array capacity: 512), Reported Axes=8 (Array capacity: 64)
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad configured. JS socket: /tmp/selkies_js0.sock, EVDEV socket: /tmp/selkies_event1000.sock. Using fixed config: Microsoft X-Box 360 pad
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Initialized and started persistent gamepad instance for index 0 (Name: 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', JS: /tmp/selkies_js0.sock, EVDEV: /tmp/selkies_event1000.sock).
webtop  | INFO:root:Packed js_config payload for 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad' (js1): len=1360 bytes. Name='Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', Vendor=0x045e, Product=0x028e, Version=0x0100, Reported Buttons=13 (Array capacity: 512), Reported Axes=8 (Array capacity: 64)
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad configured. JS socket: /tmp/selkies_js1.sock, EVDEV socket: /tmp/selkies_event1001.sock. Using fixed config: Microsoft X-Box 360 pad
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Initialized and started persistent gamepad instance for index 1 (Name: 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', JS: /tmp/selkies_js1.sock, EVDEV: /tmp/selkies_event1001.sock).
webtop  | INFO:root:Packed js_config payload for 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad' (js2): len=1360 bytes. Name='Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', Vendor=0x045e, Product=0x028e, Version=0x0100, Reported Buttons=13 (Array capacity: 512), Reported Axes=8 (Array capacity: 64)
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad configured. JS socket: /tmp/selkies_js2.sock, EVDEV socket: /tmp/selkies_event1002.sock. Using fixed config: Microsoft X-Box 360 pad
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Initialized and started persistent gamepad instance for index 2 (Name: 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', JS: /tmp/selkies_js2.sock, EVDEV: /tmp/selkies_event1002.sock).
webtop  | INFO:root:Packed js_config payload for 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad' (js3): len=1360 bytes. Name='Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', Vendor=0x045e, Product=0x028e, Version=0x0100, Reported Buttons=13 (Array capacity: 512), Reported Axes=8 (Array capacity: 64)
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad configured. JS socket: /tmp/selkies_js3.sock, EVDEV socket: /tmp/selkies_event1003.sock. Using fixed config: Microsoft X-Box 360 pad
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Initialized and started persistent gamepad instance for index 3 (Name: 'Microsoft X-Box 360 pad', JS: /tmp/selkies_js3.sock, EVDEV: /tmp/selkies_event1003.sock).
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Starting clipboard monitor
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Found XFIXES version 4.0
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:starting cursor monitor
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:watching for cursor changes
webtop  | WARNING:data_websocket:Cannot broadcast cursor data: prerequisites not met.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:GStreamer bus handling loop finished.
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad /tmp/selkies_js0.sock: Event processor started.
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:JS interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_js0.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad /tmp/selkies_js1.sock: Event processor started.
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:JS interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_js1.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad /tmp/selkies_js2.sock: Event processor started.
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:JS interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_js2.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:Gamepad /tmp/selkies_js3.sock: Event processor started.
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:JS interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_js3.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:EVDEV interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_event1000.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:EVDEV interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_event1001.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:EVDEV interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_event1002.sock
webtop  | INFO:selkies_gamepad:EVDEV interposer server listening on /tmp/selkies_event1003.sock
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Data WebSocket Server listening on port 8082
webtop  | WARNING:data_websocket:Cannot broadcast cursor data: prerequisites not met.

And when I try to connect :

webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Data WebSocket connected from ('127.0.0.1', 35380)
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Broadcasting stream resolution: {"type": "stream_resolution", "width": 1024, "height": 768}
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Attempting to establish PulseAudio connection...
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:PulseAudio connection established.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Applying client settings (initial=True): {'videoBitRate': 16000000, 'videoFramerate': 60, 'videoCRF': 25, 'encoder': 'x264enc', 'h264_fullcolor': False, 'resizeRemote': True, 'isManualResolutionMode': False, 'manualWidth': 1024, 'manualHeight': 768, 'audioBitRate': 128000, 'videoBufferSize': 0, 'initialClientWidth': 1920, 'initialClientHeight': 952}
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:on_resize_handler attempting resize for: 1920x952
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:App dimensions updated to 1920x952 before xrandr call.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:Mode 1920x952 not found in xrandr list. Attempting to add for screen 'screen'.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:Successfully ran: xrandr --newmode 1920x952 150.50 1920 2032 2232 2544 952 955 965 988 -hsync +vsync
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:Successfully ran: xrandr --addmode screen 1920x952
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:Applying xrandr mode '1920x952' for screen 'screen'.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:Successfully applied xrandr mode '1920x952'.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app_resize:resize_display('1920x952') reported success.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Initial client settings processed and event set by _apply_client_settings.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Initial client settings message processed by ws_handler.
webtop  | WARNING:data_websocket:Initial setup: Video pipeline for 'x264enc' was expected to be started by _apply_client_settings but is not. This might indicate an issue or a no-op change.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Initial setup: Audio pipeline not yet active, attempting start.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:Starting WebSocket audio pipeline...
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:Building WebSocket audio pipeline...
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:Audio pipeline state change to PLAYING is ASYNC.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:WebSocket audio pipeline started.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Broadcasting stream resolution: {"type": "stream_resolution", "width": 1920, "height": 952}
webtop  | WARNING:webrtc_input:No clipboard content to send
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received START_VIDEO for encoder: x264enc
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Starting x264enc: 1920x952 @ 60.0fps, CRF: 25, FullFrame: True
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:New frame backpressure task started (current encoder: 'x264enc').
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:x264enc capture started successfully.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received START_AUDIO command from client for server-to-client audio.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:START_AUDIO: Server-to-client audio pipeline already reported as active.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task started.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Client settings received, proceeding with backpressure loop.
webtop  | X Shared Memory Extension available.
webtop  | XShm setup complete for 1920x952.
webtop  | CPU cores available: 2
webtop  | Res: 1920x952 Mode: H264 CS_IN:I420 LR FF Stripes: 1 CRF:25 EncFPS: 4.00 EncStripes/s: 4.00
webtop  | Res: 1920x952 Mode: H264 CS_IN:I420 LR FF Stripes: 1 CRF:25 EncFPS: 0.00 EncStripes/s: 0.00
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Resetting keyboard modifiers.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received STOP_VIDEO
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Stopping X11 x264-striped capture...
webtop  | Capture loop stopped. X resources released.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task cancelled.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task finished.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Backpressure task was stopped. Calling _reset_frame_ids_and_notify.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Resetting frame IDs.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Broadcasting PIPELINE_RESETTING to 1 client(s).
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Resetting keyboard modifiers.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received START_VIDEO for encoder: x264enc
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Starting x264enc: 1920x952 @ 60.0fps, CRF: 25, FullFrame: True
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:New frame backpressure task started (current encoder: 'x264enc').
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:x264enc capture started successfully.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task started.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Client settings received, proceeding with backpressure loop.
webtop  | X Shared Memory Extension available.
webtop  | XShm setup complete for 1920x952.
webtop  | CPU cores available: 2
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Resetting keyboard modifiers.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received STOP_VIDEO
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Stopping X11 x264-striped capture...
webtop  | Capture loop stopped. X resources released.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task cancelled.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task finished.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Backpressure task was stopped. Calling _reset_frame_ids_and_notify.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Resetting frame IDs.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Broadcasting PIPELINE_RESETTING to 1 client(s).
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Received START_VIDEO for encoder: x264enc
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Starting x264enc: 1920x952 @ 60.0fps, CRF: 25, FullFrame: True
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:New frame backpressure task started (current encoder: 'x264enc').
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:x264enc capture started successfully.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task started.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Client settings received, proceeding with backpressure loop.
webtop  | X Shared Memory Extension available.
webtop  | XShm setup complete for 1920x952.
webtop  | CPU cores available: 2
webtop  | INFO:webrtc_input:Resetting keyboard modifiers.
webtop  | Res: 1920x952 Mode: H264 CS_IN:I420 LR FF Stripes: 1 CRF:25 EncFPS: 2.00 EncStripes/s: 2.00
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Cleaning up Data WS handler for ('127.0.0.1', 35380)...
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Last client (('127.0.0.1', 35380)) disconnected. Cancelling frame backpressure task.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:No other clients in set after ('127.0.0.1', 35380) disconnected. Marking pipelines for stop.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Stopping global pipelines due to last client disconnect (('127.0.0.1', 35380)).
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Stopping X11 x264-striped capture...
webtop  | WARNING:data_websocket:Cannot broadcast GStreamer audio: data_streaming_server.clients not available or empty. Scheduling audio pipeline shutdown.
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:Stopping WebSocket audio pipeline...
webtop  | INFO:gst_app:WebSocket audio pipeline stopped.
webtop  | Capture loop stopped. X resources released.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task cancelled.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task finished.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Backpressure task was stopped. Calling _reset_frame_ids_and_notify.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Resetting frame IDs.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame IDs reset, but no clients to notify.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Data WS handler for ('127.0.0.1', 35380) finished all cleanup.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Frame-based backpressure logic task started.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Client settings received, proceeding with backpressure loop.
webtop  | INFO:data_websocket:Stats sender: WS connection closed.

[thelamer]

are you not using https ?

[thefaboss]

Not right now, but when it will work, I'll put a certbot and reverse proxy with Apache.

I'm confused because an old version of webtop (with KSM VNC) still work great ^^

[thelamer]

https is a hard requirement here I am gonna use boomer caps so everyone in the thread can hear it

HTTPS IS A HARD REQUIREMENT NOW USE PORT 3001 OR USE 3000 BEHING A REVERSE PROXY
HTTPS IS A HARD REQUIREMENT NOW USE PORT 3001 OR USE 3000 BEHING A REVERSE PROXY
HTTPS IS A HARD REQUIREMENT NOW USE PORT 3001 OR USE 3000 BEHING A REVERSE PROXY
HTTPS IS A HARD REQUIREMENT NOW USE PORT 3001 OR USE 3000 BEHING A REVERSE PROXY

[thefaboss]

Gonna try with HTTPS -_-'

[thefaboss]

It works better with a HTTPS.
Thx for your help :)