MiGraphx CPU/GPU Status Tracking

[zjgarvey]

This issue will be used to track compilation failures for migraphx models on CPU and GPU. Compile failures for each model should have a link to an issue with a smaller reproducer in the notes column.

Notes:

1. migraphx_ORT__bert_base_cased_1 fails on CPU but passes on GPU. Other adjacent models fail for similar reasons on both. Very odd.
2. not including tests migraphx_sdxl__unet__model, migraphx_ORT__bert_large_uncased_1 because they cause a crash (likely OOM)
3. not including any of the tf models yet.

CPU Status Table

The Following report was generated with IREE compiler version iree-org/iree@caacf6c
Torch-mlir version llvm/torch-mlir@2665ed3

Passing Summary

TOTAL TESTS = 30

Stage	# Passing	% of Total	% of Attempted
Setup	30	100.0%	100.0%
IREE Compilation	24	80.0%	80.0%
Gold Inference	22	73.3%	91.7%
IREE Inference Invocation	19	63.3%	86.4%
Inference Comparison (PASS)	15	50.0%	78.9%

Fail Summary

TOTAL TESTS = 30

Stage	# Failed at Stage	% of Total
Setup	0	0.0%
IREE Compilation	6	20.0%
Gold Inference	2	6.7%
IREE Inference Invocation	3	10.0%
Inference Comparison	4	13.3%

Test Run Detail

Test was run with the following arguments:
Namespace(device='local-task', backend='llvm-cpu', iree_compile_args=None, mode='cl-onnx-iree', torchtolinalg=True, stages=None, skip_stages=None, benchmark=False, load_inputs=False, groups='all', test_filter='migraphx', testsfile=None, tolerance=None, verbose=True, rundirectory='test-run', no_artifacts=False, cleanup='0', report=True, report_file='mi_10_10.md')

Test	Exit Status	Mean Benchmark Time (ms)	Notes
migraphx_agentmodel__AgentModel	compilation	None	iree-18268 iree-18412 torch-mlir-3651
migraphx_bert__bert-large-uncased	preprocessing	None
migraphx_bert__bertsquad-12	Numerics	None
migraphx_cadene__dpn92i1	PASS	None
migraphx_cadene__inceptionv4i16	PASS	None
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di1	PASS	None
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di16	PASS	None
migraphx_huggingface-transformers__bert_mrpc8	native_inference	None
migraphx_mlperf__bert_large_mlperf	Numerics	None
migraphx_mlperf__resnet50_v1	PASS	None
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-decoder	compiled_inference	None
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-encoder	native_inference	None
migraphx_onnx-misc__taau_low_res_downsample_d2s_for_infer_time_fp16_opset11	import_model	None
migraphx_onnx-model-zoo__gpt2-10	preprocessing	None
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_cased_1	PASS	None
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_uncased_1	PASS	None
migraphx_ORT__bert_large_uncased_1	PASS	None
migraphx_ORT__distilgpt2_1	compiled_inference	None
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_base_cased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics	None
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_large_uncased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics	None
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__distilgpt2_1_fp16_gpu	compiled_inference	None
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_gru	PASS	None
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_lstm	PASS	None
migraphx_sd__unet__model	import_model	None
migraphx_sdxl__unet__model	import_model	None
migraphx_torchvision__densenet121i32	PASS	None
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni1	PASS	None
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni32	PASS	None
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i1	PASS	None
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i64	PASS	None

OLD STATUS (Will update and migrate issues to current table)

Test	Exit Status	Notes
migraphx_agentmodel__AgentModel	compilation
migraphx_bert__bert-large-uncased	compilation	iree-18269 Two IR reported under this, depicting different behavior
migraphx_bert__bertsquad-12	compilation	iree-18267 torch-mlir-3647
migraphx_cadene__dpn92i1	PASS
migraphx_cadene__inceptionv4i16	PASS
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di1	PASS
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di16	PASS
migraphx_huggingface-transformers__bert_mrpc8	compilation	iree-18413
migraphx_mlperf__bert_large_mlperf	compilation	iree-18297
migraphx_mlperf__resnet50_v1	PASS
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-decoder	compilation	torch-mlir-3647
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-encoder	compilation	torch-mlir-3647
migraphx_onnx-misc__taau_low_res_downsample_d2s_for_infer_time_fp16_opset11	construct_inputs	ORT issue with resize with f16 inputs?
migraphx_onnx-model-zoo__gpt2-10	compilation	shark-turbine-465 torch-mlir-615 torch-mlir-3293
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_cased_1	Numerics	Passed when '--iree-input-demote-i64-to-i32' is not present iree-18273
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_uncased_1	Numerics	Passed when '--iree-input-demote-i64-to-i32' is not present
migraphx_ORT__bert_large_uncased_1	compilation	crashes "MatMul" fail to legalize stream.cmd.dispatch iree-org/iree#18229 llvm/torch-mlir#3647 ??
migraphx_ORT__distilgpt2_1	Numerics
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_base_cased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_large_uncased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__distilgpt2_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_gru	Numerics	iree-18441
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_lstm	Numerics	iree-18441
migraphx_sd__unet__model	import_model	Killed during MLIR import. Too big??
migraphx_sdxl__unet__model	import_model	Killed during MLIR import. Too big??
migraphx_torchvision__densenet121i32	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni1	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni32	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i1	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i64	PASS

GPU Status Table

last generated with pip installed iree tools at version

iree-compiler      20240903.1005
iree-runtime       20240903.1005

Summary

Stage	Count
Total	21 (non-crashing, see table below)
PASS	12
Numerics	2
results-summary	0
postprocessing	0
compiled_inference	up to 5 (not included in total) crash during this stage
compilation	4
preprocessing	0
import_model	1
native_inference	2
construct_inputs	0
setup	0

Test Run Detail

Test was run with the following arguments:
Namespace(device='hip://1', backend='rocm', iree_compile_args=['iree-hip-target=gfx942'], mode='onnx-iree', torchtolinalg=False, stages=None, skip_stages=None, load_inputs=False, groups='all', test_filter='migraphx', tolerance=None, verbose=True, rundirectory='test-run', no_artifacts=False, report=True, report_file='9_3_migraphx.md')

Test	Exit Status	Notes
migraphx_agentmodel__AgentModel	compilation	related : llvm/torch-mlir#3630
migraphx_bert__bert-large-uncased	compilation	operand return type issue (see CPU table)
migraphx_bert__bertsquad-12	compilation (without shape inference)/ compiled_inference	1. Failing to use shape inference torch-mlir passes in torch-to-iree pipeline gives an all dynamic squeeze-dim op. 2. If using torch-lower-to-backend-contract to get the shape information, this crashes during inference with OOB memory access
migraphx_cadene__dpn92i1	PASS
migraphx_cadene__inceptionv4i16	PASS
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di1	PASS
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di16	PASS
migraphx_huggingface-transformers__bert_mrpc8	native_inference
migraphx_mlperf__bert_large_mlperf	native_inference
migraphx_mlperf__resnet50_v1	PASS
migraphx_onnx-misc__taau_low_res_downsample_d2s_for_infer_time_fp16_opset11	import_model
migraphx_onnx-model-zoo__gpt2-10	compilation	nod-ai/SHARK-ModelDev#465 llvm/torch-mlir#615 llvm/torch-mlir#3293
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_cased_1	PASS
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_uncased_1	PASS
migraphx_ORT__distilgpt2_1	likely compiled_inference	crashes with "Memory access fault by GPU node-3 (Agent handle: 0x5595fe450840) on address 0x7f1811a56000. Reason: Unknown."
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_base_cased_1_fp16_gpu	compiled_inference	causes a hard crash for trying to access memory out of bounds (Mi300x)
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_large_uncased_1_fp16_gpu	compiled_inference	same crash as above
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__distilgpt2_1_fp16_gpu	likely compiled_inference	crashes with "Memory access fault by GPU node-3 (Agent handle: 0x5595fe450840) on address 0x7f1811a56000. Reason: Unknown."
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_gru	Numerics
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_lstm	Numerics
migraphx_torchvision__densenet121i32	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni1	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni32	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i1	PASS
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i64	PASS

Note: GPU missing sd model (runs out of memory and kills the test). Probably happening during native inference, so it might need some looking into.

Performance data with iree-benchmark-module on GPU

Summary

Stage	Count
Total	30
PASS	13
Numerics	3
results-summary	0
postprocessing	0
benchmark	0
compiled_inference	2
native_inference	1
construct_inputs	0
compilation	8
preprocessing	0
import_model	3
setup	0

Test Run Detail

Test was run with the following arguments:
Namespace(device='local-task', backend='llvm-cpu', iree_compile_args=None, mode='cl-onnx-iree', torchtolinalg=False, stages=None, skip_stages=None, benchmark=True, load_inputs=False, groups='all', test_filter='migraphx', testsfile=None, tolerance=None, verbose=True, rundirectory='test-run', no_artifacts=False, cleanup='0', report=True, report_file='report.md')

Test	Exit Status	Mean Benchmark Time (ms)	Notes
migraphx_agentmodel__AgentModel	compilation	None
migraphx_bert__bert-large-uncased	compilation	None
migraphx_bert__bertsquad-12	compilation	None
migraphx_cadene__dpn92i1	PASS	457.4397828740378
migraphx_cadene__inceptionv4i16	PASS	26072.668661984306
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di1	PASS	995.6825857516378
migraphx_cadene__resnext101_64x4di16	PASS	6324.309662605326
migraphx_huggingface-transformers__bert_mrpc8	compilation	None
migraphx_mlperf__bert_large_mlperf	PASS	8195.630943014596
migraphx_mlperf__resnet50_v1	PASS	219.81522629761858
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-decoder	compiled_inference	None
migraphx_models__whisper-tiny-encoder	native_inference	None
migraphx_onnx-misc__taau_low_res_downsample_d2s_for_infer_time_fp16_opset11	import_model	None
migraphx_onnx-model-zoo__gpt2-10	compilation	None
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_cased_1	PASS	817.4834945239127
migraphx_ORT__bert_base_uncased_1	compilation	None
migraphx_ORT__bert_large_uncased_1	PASS	2728.984761983156
migraphx_ORT__distilgpt2_1	compiled_inference	None
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_base_cased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics	2141.3577783387154
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__bert_large_uncased_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics	6767.566671983029
migraphx_ORT__onnx_models__distilgpt2_1_fp16_gpu	Numerics	101.96079453453422
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_gru	compilation	None
migraphx_pytorch-examples__wlang_lstm	compilation	None
migraphx_sd__unet__model	import_model	None
migraphx_sdxl__unet__model	import_model	None
migraphx_torchvision__densenet121i32	PASS	2639.900082334255
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni1	PASS	627.4162046611309
migraphx_torchvision__inceptioni32	PASS	22124.727455200627
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i1	PASS	284.1490000589854
migraphx_torchvision__resnet50i64	PASS	11100.900294492021

[nirvedhmeshram]

@zjgarvey added llvm/torch-mlir#3647 to some of the models as we need that along with iree-org/iree#18229

[MaheshRavishankar]

cc @lialan as well. Can you co-ordinate with Zach to track CPU codegen issues.

[nirvedhmeshram]

Also adding llvm/torch-mlir#3651 that needs to be done for supporting broad range of models.

[zjgarvey]

Updated benchmarks for static-dim bert tests on mi300:

Passing Summary

TOTAL TESTS = 18

Stage	# Passing	% of Total	% of Attempted
Setup	18	100.0%	100.0%
IREE Compilation	18	100.0%	100.0%
Gold Inference	18	100.0%	100.0%
IREE Inference Invocation	18	100.0%	100.0%
Inference Comparison (PASS)	16	88.9%	88.9%

Fail Summary

TOTAL TESTS = 18

Stage	# Failed at Stage	% of Total
Setup	0	0.0%
IREE Compilation	0	0.0%
Gold Inference	0	0.0%
IREE Inference Invocation	0	0.0%
Inference Comparison	2	11.1%

Test Run Detail

Test was run with the following arguments:
Namespace(device='hip://1', backend='rocm', iree_compile_args=['iree-hip-target=gfx942'], mode='cl-onnx-iree', torchtolinalg=False, stages=None, skip_stages=None, benchmark=True, load_inputs=False, groups='all', test_filter='migx_', testsfile=None, tolerance=None, verbose=True, rundirectory='test-run', no_artifacts=False, cleanup='0', report=True, report_file='bert-bench-11-5.md', get_metadata=False)

Test	Exit Status	Mean Benchmark Time (ms)	Notes
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_16_128	PASS	31.207363539631814
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_16_256	PASS	55.50303652834816
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_16_384	Numerics	73.14148765678208
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_1_128	PASS	13.602430612827915
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_1_256	PASS	14.240951777125396
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_1_384	PASS	19.958815195908148
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_2_128	PASS	13.128591842236526
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_2_256	PASS	13.671312931608528
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_2_384	PASS	21.517712740472167
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_32_128	PASS	62.9078254498767
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_32_256	PASS	101.5021381234484
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_32_384	Numerics	143.94597491870323
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_4_128	PASS	14.44128212411286
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_4_256	PASS	17.125056890238607
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_4_384	PASS	26.636395024326745
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_8_128	PASS	18.925565496288442
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_8_256	PASS	27.419584516722423
migx_bench_bert-large-uncased_8_384	PASS	41.23994989284113